Work

Sibling connections: an exploration of adopted people’s birth and adoptive sibling relationships across the life-span

Year: 2012
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This thesis presents a qualitative exploratory study of adopted people's birth and adoptive sibling relationships across the life-span.Very little is known at present about the longitudinal experience and meaning of these relationships.This study therefore seeks to increase knowledge about how these relationships are developed, maintained and practiced across the life-span from the adopted person's perspective.Semistructured interviews were carried out with twenty adopted adults, all of whom had knowledge of at least one birth sibling.Ten participants also had adoptive siblings, who were unrelated and also adopted into the family, or were the birth children of their adoptive parents.Two participants grew up together with one birth sibling and apart from others.Almost three-quarters of the sample who had been reunited with at least one birth sibling had been in contact with them for over 6 years.Adoptive sibling relationships were generally viewed as stable and permanent, with many similarities present to siblings who grow up together in intact families.However, the experience of being adopted, and relationship dynamics within the adoptive family, was influential with regard to how these relationships were thought about and practiced across time.Developing and maintaining relationships with birth siblings was complex, particularly as they usually met as strangers in adulthood.Four 'tasks' were associated with the process of relationship development; making sense of birth family culture, negotiating the relationship, building emotional connections and integrating the past, past and future.A psycho-social model is presented which aims to provide a 'cultural map' illustrating how birth and adoptive sibling relationships are navigated in adoption.It encompasses four domains; thinking about self, others and adoption; relating to others; cultural and personal meanings of kinship and 'family'; and contextual factors (e.g.class, gender).The insights gained from this study are used to suggest improvements in adoption social work practice with sibling groups. Chapter 8: Adoptive sibling relationships across the life-spanAdoptive sibling relationships in childhood and adolescence Adoptive sibling relationships in adulthood Summary Chapter 9: Birth sibling relationships across the life-span 193 Birth sibling relationships in childhood and adolescence Searching for and being reunited with birth siblings in adulthood Developing and experiencing birth sibling relationships in adulthood Summary Chapter 10: Discussion and implications for practice Navigating sibling relationships across the life-span Typology of adopted adults' birth sibling relationships post-reunion Implications for social work practice Limitations of the study and further research Conclusion Bibliography List of Tables and FiguresTables Page No 2.1 Typology of sibling relationships 38 6.1 Sources of recruitment to the study 128 6.2 Age, gender and ethnicity 130 6.3 Howe and Feast's (2000) typology of adoption 133 Experience 6.4 Adoption experience 134 6.5 Length of time since reunion 138 6.1 Composition of sibling relationships in childhood 132 6.2 Composition of birth sibling relationships 137 7.1 Dimensions of siblinghood 140 7.2 Judith's genogram 154 10.1 Navigating sibling relationships in adoption: A 243 psycho-social model SummaryAdoption law, policy and practice has, over time, increasingly recognised adopted children's dual connection to their birth and adoptive families, and this acceptance has led to an increase of interest in the sibling relationships of adopted people.The recognition regarding the importance of on-going support for adoptive families is also significant, and underlines a major policy shift in recognising not only birth family relationships themselves, but also their complexity for all parties.However, the legal, policy and practice focus on adoption as the dominant permanent placement choice for babies and young children has had the effect of splitting up sibling groups, with the perceive need for a permanent placement often over-riding the desire to keep a sibling group together.In addition, the consideration of contact, and especially sibling contact, how it works in practice, and the complexities it potentially presents, is still underresearched, and the voices of adopted children and adults need to be heard more through further research.Having considered the legal, policy and research context of adoption and siblings, the focus of the next chapter moves to exploring how sibling relationships are experienced across the life-span for children who grow up in intact families.An understanding of this is important in order to consider the context of the life-long implications of adoption on sibling relationships.Department of Health (1989).Children Act, London: HMSO.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W614121568
Cites: 284
Cited by: 2
Related to: 10