Work

A ‘Composite Utterances’ approach to meaning

Year: 2013
Type: book-chapter
Abstract: A 'Composite Utterances' approach to meaning N. J. Enfield In human social behavior, people build communicative sequences, move by move.These moves are never semiotically simple.Their composite nature is widely varied in kind: they may consist of a word combined with other words, a string of words combined with an intonation contour, a diagram combined with a caption, an icon combined with another icon, a spoken utterance combined with a hand gesture.By what means does an interpreter take multiple signs and draw them together into unified, meaningful packages?This chapter explores the question with special reference to one of our most familiar types of move, the speech--with--gesture composite, a classical locus of research on body, language, and communication (see other chapters of this handbook relating to gesture, and many references therein).The central question is this: How do gestures contribute to the meaning of an utterance?To answer this, we need to situate research on gesture within broader questions of research on meaning.1.1 Meaning does not begin with language In a person's vast array of communicative tools, language is surely unrivalled in its expressive richness, speed, productivity, and ease.But the interpretation of linguistic signs is ultimately driven by broader principles, principles of rational cognition in social life, principles which underlie other processes of human judgment, from house--buying to gambling to passing people on a crowded street.So, to understand meaning in human utterances, we ought not begin with language (Enfield and Levinson 2006:28).There is meaning in language for the same reason there is meaning elsewhere in our social lives: because we take signs to be public elements of cognitive processes (Peirce 1955), evidence of others' communicative intentions (Grice 1957(Grice , 1975)).Our clues for figuring out those intentions are found not only in conventional symbols like words, but in the rich iconic--indexical relations which weave threads between just about everything in sight (Peirce 1955, Silverstein 1976, Levinson 1983, Kockelman 2005).Language is just a subset of the full resources necessary for recognizing others' communicative and informative intentions.1.2 Meaning is dynamic, motivated, and concrete Among fashions of thinking about language over the last century, a dominant neo--Saussurean view says that meaning is a representational relation of phonological form to conceptual content: A sign has meaning because it specifies a standing--for relation between a signifier and a signified.Semanticists of many different kinds agree on this (cf.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W614517046
FWCI: 3.1
Cites: 47
Cited by: 23
Related to: 7