Work

The Way and the Word: Science and Medicine in Early China and Greece

Year: 2015
Type: book-review
Abstract: Lloyd and Sivin have been engaged for over a decade on a project of which this book is the first full-length joint publication.They aim to explore the 'beginnings of science and medicine in early China and Greece ' [xi], covering the six centuries 400 BC to 200 AD; and they do this by delineating them through comparison of what they call the 'cultural manifold' of science in each civilization.By 'cultural manifold' they mean the continuum of thinkers' concepts, social goals, professional milieu, mode of discourse, and political associations [xixii, 3].They focus on two questions, that of the circumstances of the origins of inquiry about the natural world, and that of the paths that those inquiries opened.Their intended readers are those curious about Greek or Chinese science and their respective manifolds, or those who seek a novel viewpoint thereon.The authors do not expect deep or extensive knowledge of Greek or Chinese social or intellectual history, although Lloyd learned Chinese for the purpose of the project.The importance and novelty of their results warrants a detailed summary, and their approach deserves further exploration.I should mention at the outset that, whereas I was privileged to attend two of the early lecture series of this project that were held at Cornell in 1993 and 1995, I offer this review from the perspective of a student of Greek science who has spent some time reading up on ancient China but who cannot read Chinese.As is often the case for books that bridge disciplines, few to no reviewers exist who have all the requisite training.I do not know Sivin's work, which treats ancient Chinese alchemy, cosmology, and medicine; but this book stands in the ranks of Lloyd's works exploring the origins of Greek science,
Institution: Yale University
Language: English
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W624218905
Cites: 6
Cited by: 142
Related to: 9