Work

Time in Nicolai Hartmann's philosophy

Year: 2015
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The present work is divided into two parts. The first (only in Italian) is an analysis of some texts \nabout time in Nicolai Hartmann's works, and especially in Möglichkeit und Wirklichkeit (1938) and \nPhilosophie der Natur (1950). The second part is a theoretical discussion of one of the main \nproblems concerning time in the contemporary philosophy (and in the philosophy of physics in \nparticular), i.e., the problem of the unreality of time. Some recent theses will be compared and \nanalyzed in the light of Hartmann's critical ontology. \nThe scope of Part II is to evaluate whether and how Hartmannian arguments and theses may have \na role in the present debate. In order to introduce those positions, Part I is not thought to be an \nexhaustive dissertation about time in Hartmann's philosophy, but only an attempt to interpret some \naspects of his view about this issue in the wider contest of his analysis of the Realsein. \nThus, ch. 1 treats the basic notion of "category" in Hartmann's critical ontology and in particular \nin the third volume of his tetralogy, Der Aufbau der realen Welt (1940). There is also a brief account \nof his position about realism. Ch. 2 faces the relation between time and reality, which is defined in a \ndouble manner, namely, as the sphere of the individual being and as the kingdom of becoming. The \nlatter definition depends on Hartmann's modal analysis (in Möglichkeit und Wirklichkeit) and \nderives from the connection of modality with temporality. Ch. 3 consists in an exposition of the \nmain theses about the Realzeit (real time), exposed in Philosophie der Natur. In ch. 4 I try to make a \nbrief survey of some important problems in the contemporary philosophy of time. In ch. 5 I discuss \nthe problem of the "disappearance of spacetime", emerged in the current debate around the \ntheoretical results of the quantum gravity research program. I present, moreover, the objections that \nHartmann would have raised against that thesis. In ch. 6, finally, I try to do the same with the socalled \n"problem of frozen time" in quantum gravity and general relativity.
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W635548385
Cites: 195
Cited by:
Related to: 10