The Deliberative Deficit: Diagnosing and Reforming India's Declining Parliamentary Productivity
Year: 2025
Type: article
Abstract: This paper investigates the phenomenon of the 'deliberative deficit' within the Indian Parliament, characterized by a quantifiable decline in its legislative productivity and oversight functions. Employing a descriptive-analytical methodology, it synthesizes quantitative data from parliamentary records and PRS Legislative Research with qualitative analysis of academic literature, expert commentary, and legal frameworks. The analysis reveals a multi-decadal trend of diminishing sitting days, truncated debates, underutilization of accountability mechanisms like Question Hour, and a precipitous decline in the referral of Bills to Parliamentary Committees. The paper diagnoses the root causes of this deficit, attributing it to a confluence of factors: intensifying political polarization, the ascendancy of the executive branch, particularly during periods of single-party majority, and the constraining effects of the Anti-Defection Law on legislative dissent. A comparative analysis with Westminster systems in the United Kingdom and Canada highlights systemic gaps in Indian parliamentary practice. The paper concludes by proposing a holistic framework of institutional, procedural, and legal reforms aimed at revitalizing Parliament's deliberative capacity. These recommendations include mandating a minimum number of sitting days, strengthening the committee system, amending the Anti-Defection Law to balance party discipline with legislative freedom, and institutionalizing pre-legislative consultation to restore Parliament's role as the central forum for democratic deliberation and accountability.
Author: Devesh
Institution: Indira Gandhi National Open University
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6893366629
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: