Work

Sex differences in the manifestation of ADHD: A longitudinal examination

Year: 2023
Type: study-registration
Abstract: Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is the most common childhood neurodevelopmental disorder that affects approximately 5% of children around the globe. ADHD in childhood and adolescence is more prevalent in boys than girls, with the male-to-female ratio around 6:1 in clinical samples and 3:1 in community-based samples (Hinshaw, 2018). Over time, sex differences in ADHD prevalence appear to narrow at middle adolescence, around the age of 14-16, when ADHD and internalizing symptoms peak in girls (Dalsgaard et al., 2020). Despite the convergence of incidence rates in adolescence, psychological impairment diverges between boys and girls who experience ADHD symptoms. Girls diagnosed with ADHD are more likely to display chronic (or persistent) symptoms and functional impairment, whereas boys’ symptoms appear to decrease across adolescence, at least on average (De Ronda et al., 2023; Gaub & Carlson, 1997; Rucklidge & Tannock, 2001). In addition to differences in developmental trajectories of ADHD and associated functional impairment between girls and boys, ADHD appears associated with different comorbidity patterns depending on sex. Girls diagnosed with ADHD experience higher rates of disordered eating, social problems, depression, non-suicide self-injury, and suicidality (Beauchaine et al., 2019), each of are classified under internalizing (Watson et al., 2022). In contrast, boys with ADHD experience higher rates of substance use problems, antisocial personality disorder, and conduct problems (De Rossi et al., 2022; Owens et al., 2017; Rucklidge, 2010), each of which is classified as forms of externalizing, or conditions characterized by poor behavioral and emotional control (Krueger et al., 2021). Ultimately, much literature suggests that girls with ADHD symptoms are more likely than boys to experience internalizing and boys are more likely than girls to experience externalizing (De Rossi et al., 2022, 2022; Owens et al., 2017; Rucklidge, 2010). Given the severe lifespan consequences associated with ADHD in both girls and boys, it is crucial to understand sex differences in patterns of ADHD co-occurring symptoms. To this end, some studies have explicitly tested whether the relationship between ADHD and other forms of psychopathology was moderated by sex. Baldwin and Dadds (2008) found among a community sample of 8–13-year-olds that the association between inattention and anxiety was especially pronounced in girls compared with boys, and Welkie and colleagues (2021) observed that ADHD was more associated with emotion dysregulation in women compared with men. Existing literature has largely converged on the conclusion that ADHD manifests as more externalizing among boys and more internalizing among girls (Beauchaine et al., 2019). Nevertheless, Biederman and colleagues (2005) found no evidence that sex moderated the association between ADHD diagnosis or subtypes (i.e., inattentive, hyperactive/impulsive) and multi-domain functioning, including psychiatric comorbidity and functional impairment, in a community sample of youth aged 6-17. Given the mixed literature and that some researchers interpret sex differences in the manifestation of ADHD as evidence of sex-based dimorphic trajectories of ADHD, whether and how sex moderates ADHD’s association with functioning broadly construed warrants clarification. One factor that may contribute to a failure to detect sex differences in the expression of ADHD surrounds who is reporting ADHD and its correlates. For instance, in a non-referred community sample of children aged 6-14, Tahıllıoğlu et al. (2021) found that parent reported behavioral problems were more predictive of ADHD in girls than were teacher reported problems. Further, Pocuca and colleagues (2022) found a three-way interaction between ADHD symptoms, sex, and informant such that the interaction between inattentive symptoms and substance use in girls held only when ADHD symptoms were self-reported as opposed to other-reported (i.e., parent or teacher; Pocuca et al., 2022). Although the nature of this three-way interaction is unclear, the broader literature on informant differences suggests that they arise due to at least two factors: (1) genuine contextual variation in the expression of ADHD and other psychopathology and (2) reporter bias (De Los Reyes et al., 2023; Hartman et al., 2007). Indeed, Hartman and colleagues (2007) found that phenotypic variation in ADHD shared among parents and teachers was attributed to both rater-specific bias and contextual variation in ADHD symptoms, such that rater differences arose because raters observed different symptoms in different contexts. In general, parent reports appeared more contingent to rater bias than teacher reports (Hartman et al., 2007; Power et al., 1998). Hence, the extent of sex differences in the manifestation of ADHD may hinge on the informant used, underscoring the need for assessing multi-informant reported psychopathology. Such informant differences further complicate how we understand differential comorbidity profiles across ADHD symptoms and sex. Current Study The current study aims to comprehensively inform how biological sex moderates the expression of ADHD in a large sample of youth (N = 11,878, 48% female) who participated in the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) Study. Given the mixed findings and limitations associated with the existing literature, we designed this study to increment it in 4 key ways: 1. We will examine a broad swath of characteristics relevant to ADHD, including other forms of psychopathology, allied temperamental characteristics (e.g., effortful control, negative emotionality), functional impairment, and neurocognitive task performance. 2. We will integrate data from three reporters: the youth, a caregiver, and their primary teacher. Although self-reports bear a unique subjective perspective of one’s impairment and dysfunctions, they have not been used as frequently in studies of childhood ADHD. In the context of this study, it is possible that the inclusion of youth reports on their own psychopathology may reveal additional evidence of informant differences. 3. We will examine sex differences in a global ADHD score and individual symptoms given that sex differences appear to arise for narrower components of ADHD (e.g., inattention, hyperactivity/impulsivity, e.g., Baldwin & Dadds, 2008). 4. We will use longitudinal data to examine replication of concurrent (i.e., cross-sectional) associations across development. The ABCD Study follows preteen individuals annually (aged 9-10 at baseline) and tracks their mental and physical health development, with assessments of psychopathology available from three independent raters. The current data release (Data Release 5.0) for ABCD contains data from four waves, with the final wave assessing ADHD and other psychopathology when the youth are aged 12 to 13. The multi-wave longitudinal structure of the ABCD study allows us to replicate concurrent (cross-sectional) findings across development.
Authors: Watts, Ashley L., Zheyue Peng
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6925249579
Cites:
Cited by: 3
Related to: 10