Complexiteit ontward: een veelzijdige analyse van de wisselwerking van kwantitatieve en kwalitatieve jobonzekerheid vanuit longitudinaal perspectief
Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Untangling the Complexity: A Diversified Approach to Longitudinal Analysis of the Interplay between Quantitative and Qualitative Job Insecurity. The labour market in the aftermath of the pandemic has entered a phase of unprecedented evolution, driven by global economic recovery efforts. While certain sectors have witnessed a rebound, others continue to grapple with ongoing challenges and uncertainties. In response to changing circumstances, organisations adapt by embracing remote work as a prevalent practice. Furthermore, advancements in digital transformation and automation (e.g., the rise of AI) result in rapid shifts in job roles and skill requirements. Consequently, the labour market has become increasingly volatile, leading to heightened perceptions of both quantitative (i.e., the perceived threat of job loss) and qualitative job insecurity (i.e., the perceived threat of losing valued job features). Despite the familiarity with job insecurity, there remains a paucity of research designed to understand the relationship between these two dimensions. This dissertation’s aim is twofold. First, we apply a theoretical framework to elucidate the relationship between quantitative and qualitative job insecurity. Second, we employ the latest data analysis methods and statistical inference techniques to overcome common methodological barriers in work and organisational psychology research. Specifically, we address the second aim guided by three objectives: 1) conducting a longitudinal analysis to examine the associations between these dimensions over time, 2) distinguishing within-person and between-person effects, and 3) employing both variable-centred and person-centred approaches. We conducted three empirical studies and used two longitudinal datasets gathered among the Belgian population. The first dataset, which was used in studies 1 and 3, is a three-wave panel data gathered among 2355 Flemish employees between 2017/2018. The second dataset, which was used in Study 2, is a three-wave panel data gathered among 4981 Flemish and Walloon employees between 2013/2014. In the first study, we conducted a cross-lagged panel model to estimate the temporal stability of and the lagged effects between quantitative and qualitative job insecurity. Our findings showed significant and stable carry-over effects (autoregressive process) for quantitative and qualitative job insecurity, which indicates that job insecurity is relatively stable at the population level. Furthermore, we found that qualitative job insecurity was positively associated with quantitative job insecurity six months later. In the second study, prior to analysing autoregressive and cross-lagged effects, we disaggregated the between-person and within-person effects. We found that over 60% of the variation in quantitative and qualitative job insecurity is due to individual differences (between-person variance). We employed a random-intercept cross-lagged panel model to control for the between-person variance when exploring the relationship at the within-person level. The results indicated that, when controlling for between-person variance, the intraindividual autoregressive paths were significant (however, weaker than in study 1) for quantitative but not qualitative job insecurity. In addition, compared to Study 1, we found a reverse relationship between quantitative and qualitative job insecurity. The results indicated that an employee who experiences a higher-than-usual threat to job loss (i.e., quantitative job insecurity) is more likely to experience a higher-than-usual threat to job characteristics (i.e., qualitative job insecurity) six months later. In study 3, we used a person-centred approach and conducted latent class growth analysis to investigate parallel trajectories for quantitative and qualitative job insecurity. We found five distinct classes of job insecurity trajectories that varied in their base level and shape of experienced job insecurity. Whereas in four out of five trajectories, employees experienced similar base levels of both dimensions (high, moderate, low), a fifth of the sample (≈20%) experienced a high threat to job characteristics (i.e., high qualitative job insecurity) and simultaneously felt secure about keeping their job (i.e., low quantitative job insecurity). In sum, our results demonstrate the complexity of both quantitative and qualitative job insecurity and the processes of the interdependency between the two dimensions of job insecurity. Although we found no evidence for a reciprocal relationship, the results suggest that the relationship between quantitative job insecurity occurs in both directions. Altogether, this project corroborates employing longitudinal designs, a person-centred approach, and within-person analysis in work and organisational psychology, considering the extensive insights gained regarding the development and interdependence of the two prevalent psychosocial work stressors— quantitative and qualitative job insecurity.
Source: Lirias
Author: Nawrocka, Sonia
Institutions: University of Verona, KU Leuven
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6980676433
