The Costs of Inaction: Calculating climate change-related loss and damage from extreme weather in Small Island Developing States
Year: 2023
Type: report
Abstract: Small Island Developing States (SIDS) have had considerable success in getting climate-induced loss and damage on to the international policy agenda, as evidenced by the decision at COP27 to create a specific Loss and Damage Fund. However, the hard task of harnessing adequate support to address loss and damage hinges on being able to calculate what constitutes 'loss' and 'damage', both retrospectively and prospectively. This paper contributes to that conversation. It presents estimates of the impacts of extreme weather events due to climate change in SIDS over the past 23 years and projections of expected loss and damage by the year 2050.Using information from extreme event attribution (EEA) analysis, this paper finds significant loss and damage attributable to climate change in SIDS: from 2000 to 2022, a total of 10,113 deaths associated with extreme weather events were recorded in SIDS, of which anthropogenic climate change was responsible for 38%. Annual economic losses of US$1.7 billion can be attributed to climate change, representing 0.8% of the collective gross domestic product (GDP) of SIDS every year. For small, undiversified SIDS economies, this is extremely significant. On average, SIDS suffer higher levels of loss and damage than non-SIDS across all income groups. For instance, SIDS experience five times more climate change-attributable deaths (per million of population) than non-SIDS in low- and lower middle-income countries.Collectively, floods and storms are projected to produce cumulative climate change-attributable loss and damage of $56 billion in SIDS under a 2°C warming scenario by 2050. This would represent 11% higher average annual loss and damage over the next 23 years (2023–2045) than over the past 23 years (2000–2022). These projections likely underestimate the potential loss and damage that may occur in SIDS, because of limited data and because indirect economic impacts (e.g. loss of GDP, loss of revenues) and loss and damage due to slow-onset events have not been included in the analysis.The paper offers recommendations to help inform the development of adequate financial mechanisms, including the Loss and Damage Fund, for coping with these seemingly inevitable impacts of climate change in SIDS. Firstly, mechanisms to address loss and damage need to focus on loss and damage under a 2°C+ scenario. Secondly, there needs to be a clearer articulation, and calculation, of the indirect costs of climate change, which could be significant. And finally, data gaps need to be filled as a matter of urgency, including through more attribution studies in SIDS and other highly vulnerable countries.Â
Source: Issue Lab (Candid)
Authors: Vikrant Panwar, Ilan Noy, Emily Wilkinson, Jack Corbett
Language: English
Subfield: Global and Planetary Change
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
SDG: Climate action
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6980765455
