Dienend leiderschap en derde partij conflict gedrag: dienen tot welzijn van religieuze vrouwen
Year: 2021
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: This dissertation investigates the role of leadership in Catholic convents where religious sisters live and work together. More specifically, this doctoral research examines the relationship between servant and authoritarian leadership and sisters' psychological and spiritual wellbeing, mediated by team trust and team conflict, and the third-party conflict behavior of these leaders. The current PhD project investigates this theme through four empirical chapters. Data were collected from 453 religious sisters (followers) and 92 local community leaders (local superiors) from the religious institute. The dissertation discusses this quantitative data in depth, focusing on the perceptions and experiences of the followers. To gain an in-depth understanding of the context, I also conducted semi-structured interviews with sisters and their leaders. Additionally, I studied the values, vocational training, vision on leadership as well as the current leadership and HRM practices through documentary analyses. Chapter 1 presents an overall introduction. I describe the context of the study based on the documentary analyses, and the theoretical framework of our studies. Chapter 2 describes the first quantitative study: The relationships between servant and authoritarian leadership on the one hand, and leaders' third-party conflict behavior; avoiding, forcing and problem solving, on the other hand. Results show that servant leadership is positively related to leaders' problem-solving strategies and negatively related to avoiding and forcing behaviors in conflicts between sisters. Authoritarian leadership in contrast, relates positively to avoiding and forcing third party behaviors, and negatively to problem solving. In Chapter 3 we investigate the mediating role of team trust in the relationship of servant and authoritarian leadership with followers' wellbeing; their engagement and affective commitment. A mixed method research design was used, with quantitative data and archival analysis. Results from the quantitative data analysis confirm the relevance of servant leadership and the mediating role of team trust on engagement and affective commitment of religious sisters (followers). Further findings reveal that authoritarian leadership relates negatively to team trust, thereby reduces followers' engagement and their affective commitment. Archival analysis further corroborates that servant leadership promotes followers' trust in each other, thereby fostering their engagement and affective commitment at work and in the local religious communities due to the daily reality and the spirit and charism of the religious community life. In Chapter 4 we examine whether servant leadership is associated with reduced followers' emotional exhaustion through the mediating role of leaders' third-party conflict behaviors- avoiding, forcing and problem solving, as well as reduced team conflict. Results show that servant leadership is associated with a direct decrease in sisters' team conflict experience, and with an indirect decrease in this conflict experience through increased use of problem solving, and less use of avoiding or forcing behaviors. This in turn, specifically, less use of forcing behavior translates into sisters' lower experienced emotional exhaustion. In Chapter 5 we measure Gifts and Fruits of the Spirit to assess spiritual wellbeing. We found servant leadership and team trust to associate with higher spiritual wellbeing in convents. In Chapter 6 we summarize our main findings, provide recommendations for developing servant leadership, third party problem solving behavior and team trust in practice, and provide avenues for future research.
Source: Lirias (KU Leuven)
Author: Obi, Innocentina
Institution: KU Leuven
Language: English
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: servant leadership, authoritarian leadership, Catholic convents, women religious, team trust, team conflict, affective commitment, engagement, emotional exhaustion, conflict avoidance, Catholic women's religious life, human resource management practices, vocational education, leadership values, spiritual gifts, follower perceptions
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6981167464
