Work

Habituating Wild Primates: Ethics of the Researcher-Subject Relationship and Its Implications for Field Research Methodology

Year: 2023
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Habituation is the process of exposing an individual to a neutral stimulus until they become accustomed to it. In nonhuman animal field research, scientists must initially present themselves as non-threatening, neutral entities to their animal subjects, as the animals initially flee from them. Over time, the subjects allow the scientists to follow them, and the animals are assumed to return to their ‘natural’ behavior. For particularly intelligent and social animals, such as primates, this process can take as little as a month, but it can take up to fifteen years. Several potential impacts of habituation can harm the welfare of primates or make them vulnerable, for instance, to disease transfer and poaching. Primatologists have been particularly vocal and concerned about these impacts of habituation. However, the uniqueness of field sites, limited resources, and lack of consensus makes it difficult to guide ethical behavior. Within philosophical literature, discussions on our ethical obligations to wild animals have mostly regarded generic responsibilities or individual, isolated situations—little attention has been paid to continuous, long-term relationships between humans and wild individuals. To help guide primatologists, I turn to the professional ethics literature and draw on Beauchamp and Childress’s midlevel principles, which are flexible and balanced, to develop guidelines for primatologists regarding habituation. Based on the values and concerns expressed by the profession, I construct and develop three midlevel principles for primatologists: 1) noninterference in welfare, 2) behavioral reciprocity, and 3) protection from habituation-caused vulnerability. I have designed these principles to help primatologists decide whether, in any particular case, it is appropriate and permissible to habituate primates and, if so, how to do so in a way that minimizes the negative impacts of habituation.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6982139886
Cites: 153
Cited by:
Related to: 10