Organization and desynchronization of circadian rhythms in italian nursing and midwifery: social and working activities
Year: 2021
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: INTRODUCTION: Biological rhythms are present in all living organisms. The circadian rhythm (from the latin circa dies), with a duration of approximately 24 hours, is the most commonly studied in human beings. Biological rhythms are characterized by multiple molecular mechanisms aiming at synchronization and adaptation of organism to the temporal variations of environment. The circadian individual preference (chronotype) represents the phenotypic manifestation of such a complex mechanism, in many behavioral and daily living aspects. As far the late 70’s of the last century, Horne and Ostberg identified individual differences in circadian attitudes and defined different chronotypes by means of a self-assessed questionnaires with a defined score. Belonging to a defined chronotype seems to have an impact on everydays activities including working. On the other hand, the biological circadian rhythms could be disrupted by everydays activities leading to desynchronization. It has been reported two main types of desynchronization: fast (jet lag) and slow (shift work). Recently, also tlso the change due to Daylight Saving Time (DST) has been identified as a desynchronizing condition with possible negative impact on health. Thus, the starting hypothesis of this doctoral thesis is that social and working activities and chronotype may be closely related, and desynchronization, eg, shift work and DST, should be taken into consideration in Italian midwives. OBJECTIVES: General To determine the effect of chronotype and desynchronization of circadian rhythms (shift work and DST) on social and working activities in Italian midwives. Specific - To assess individual circadian preferences, effects on sleep, and quality of life perceived by midwives. - To determine the effect of the chronotype on social and working activities. - To evaluate the association between the biannual DST and labor activity. - To determine the effect of shift work and the time change on social and work activities. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Two approaches were used: a) Observational study: by the use of validated questionnaires administered through social networks, registered midwives belonging to the Italian Board of Nursing of Midwifery were investigated during 2019. The variables evaluated were individual circadian preference, work shift, working experience, fear of medication errors and sociodemographic, such as age and educational level. A cluster analysis was carried out to know the association between variables. b) Retrospective case-control study using administrative databases: the certificates of attendance at birth generated during the period 2016-2018 in the Region of Emilia-Romagna of Italy were considered. The number of spontaneous deliveries two weeks before (control) and after DST (cases) were analyzed. Further variables, such as gestational age, type of delivery, delivery time, newborn’s weight, Apgar test 5 minutes after delivery, and the use of analgesia during delivery, were evaluated. Univariate and multivariate analyses (logistic regression analysis) were carried out. RESULTS: In the first part of the work, 401 midwives (98.8% women) were enrolled. The mean age was 38.5 }10.1 years and the most common chronotypes were intermediate (50.3%) and moderately morning (39%). Nearly fifty percent of cases self-perceived risk of medication error “at least once”. Perception of risk of medication error was associated with midwifes aged between 31-35 years, undergoing shift work, with a working experience between 6-10 years, and having an intermediate chronotype. In the second study, 7415 spontaneous deliveries were evaluated, the mean age of the women was 31.4 } 10.1 years, and gestational age 39.3 } 1.4 weeks. No significant differences were found between the number of deliveries before and after DST. There were no significant differences for the mode of delivery, gestational age and the number of spontaneous deliveries. Gestational time, newborn weight, Apgar test 5 minutes after delivery, and use of analgesia did not show statistical significance as well. Mother’s age was the only variable found to be independently associated with delivery during the two weeks after DST. CONCLUSIONS The chronotype and shift work in Italian midwives influence professional self-perception, specifically the perception of risk of medication error. Younger midwives, with lower working experience, engaged in shift work and belonging to an Intermediate chronotype, seem to be at higher risk of potential medication error. Morning hours seem to represent highest risk frame for female healthcare workers and shift work is not always aligned with individual circadian preference. Thus, some suggested practical applications could include, for example, assessment of individual chronotype and sleep attitude in healthcare personnel, specific training programs, and intervention strategies, such as time-scheduled naps during night-shifts. As for the potential rhythm disruption operated by DST, the present study did not find any differences in the number of deliveries in the weeks following time shifts. This finding is in agreement with previous data obtained at quite different conditions of latitude, climate, and light exposure. It is possible that the multihormonal etiology of labor may explain this phenomenon. Further studies extended to different latitudes and ethnicities, could be very useful to verify the possibility of a generalization.
Author: Cappadona, Rosaria
Institution: University of Córdoba
Language: English
Subfield: Experimental and Cognitive Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6986207540
