Work

Study of virucidal effects of disinfectants against murine norovirus and feline calicivirus, surrogates of human norovirus

Year: 2016
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Human noroviruses (HuNoV) are amongst the leading causes of acute non-bacterial gastroenteritis in humans and annually constitute a global public health problem involving numerous people with great medical, sanitary and economic consequences. The effects of disinfectants against viruses and more specifically against highly resistant viruses such as HuNoV in the environment are little known and data, sometimes empirically obtained, originate from effects observed with bacteria or enveloped viruses. The aim of this thesis is to evaluate disinfectant effects against HuNoV. Since in vitro culture of HuNoV remains difficult, genetically and morphologically similar viral surrogates, are utilised as indirect tools to obtain data about the virucidal effects of disinfectants. The murine norovirus (MNV) and feline calicivirus (FCV) are two frequently used HuNoV surrogates, for which an in vitro cell culture system and a plaque assay protocol exist. In the first study, the virucidal effect of seven disinfectants was evaluated in suspension tests and in two carriers tests (stainless steel and the latex gloves), using two parameters, the infectious viral titre and the genomic copy number. This first study demonstrated that three disinfectants were able to induce a viral titre reduction of more than three log10 for the two surrogates in all three kinds of tests. The disinfectants were halogen, an oxidizing agent and a mix composed of quaternary ammonium compounds (QAC), an alcohol and an aldehyde. The three disinfectants also showed a significant effect on the genomic copy number of MNV and FCV in all three kinds of tests. In conclusion, this first study demonstrates that the three disinfectants should be considered as disinfectants with likely efficiency against the HuNoV and that their use should be recommended for disinfection of surfaces or materials potentially contaminated by the HuNoV. The use of touchless disinfection technologies is gaining increasing importance due to their automatization (limited reliance on human factors), safe use and beneficial economic impact (staff is available for other work). It has been conclusively demonstrated that the environment and contaminated surfaces of health institutes and food processing industries can be a source of infection and have been involved in HuNoV transmission amongst the population in numerous instances. H2O2 nebulization is a system that aerosolizes a solution, causing it to form liquid droplets in the air. The goal of the second part of this thesis is to evaluate the effect of nebulization on the two main HuNoV surrogates, MNV and FCV, on two different surfaces, i.e. glass and stainless steel, representing the surfaces typically present in field conditions. The H2O2 nebulization was shown to be efficient, mediating a mean viral titre reduction of both surrogates of more than 4 log10, and shouldhenceforth be considered as virucidal. The reductions of genomic copies were relatively low, confirming that this parameter is not an adequate tool for the determination of virucidal efficiency of a system nebulizing H2O2. In order to reduce the risk of contamination and increase the security of consumers, patients and employees, the nebulization of H2O2 should be recommended for use as a disinfection system, complementing conventional disinfection processes in places potentially contaminated by HuNoV. After the evaluation of the effects of several disinfectants against the MNV and the FCV on the viral titre and the genomic copy number, investigation of the effect of disinfectants was continued by exploring the effect of these disinfectants on the binding step of MNV on RAW 264.7 cells. The aim of this third study was to identify whether the binding step, the first step of the viral replicative cycle, was modified after the use of disinfectants on MNV and whether this mechanism explained the virucidal effect observed in the previous studies. Via epifluorescent microscopy analysis and an indirect immunofluorescence assay, viral attachment was not observed after contact of MNV with alcohol (ethanol and isopropanol), H2O2, chlorhexidine, benzylammonium-chloride (BAC), didecyldimethyl-ammoniumchloride (DAC) at a concentration of 0.08 % or glutaraldehyde. Viral attachment was still partially observed after contact of MNV with the sodium hypochlorite or DAC at a concentration of 0.04 %. All tested disinfectants partially or totally inhibit the binding step, probably due a modification or a destruction of the MNV capsid. In conclusion, any disinfectants utilized in a disinfection process should include either a halogen product, oxidizing agents or a mix of QAC with an alcohol and an aldehyde in order to guarantee a virucidal effect against viruses such as the HuNoV. The nebulization of hydrogen peroxide should be employed both preventively and in the course of HuNoV outbreaks in places with HuNoV contamination. Amongst different mechanisms of action of virucidal disinfectants, one mechanism against MNV could be the inhibition of cellular receptor binding via structural modification of the viral capsid.
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6987468562
Cites: 294
Cited by:
Related to: 10