Year: 2019
Type: article
Abstract: This working paper has reviewed cross-national datasets for the general population and available national data and other relevant (grey and academic) literature concerned with young people in care and care leavers in the three study countries.The aim is not evaluative; i.e. not to determine which country does "best".Rather, the paper seeks to provide a situated understanding of the multi-dimensional complexity of transitions out of 'care' and of 'outcomes' for children and young people with experience of care, and hence to enable a contextualised understanding of the diversity of young people's lives and experiences.In terms of the study as a whole, the analysis presented here aims to provide a resource that will aid interpretation of the material generated in multi-method qualitative longitudinal interviews with young adults, gaining a perspective on choice and chance by understanding biographical experiences within structural contexts (Thomson and Holland, 2002), and illuminating different layers of context in cross-national comparison (Brannen and Nilsen, 2011).Consequently, the underpinning aim of this working paper has been primarily descriptive, and we have not provided a substantive discussion of cross-country variations.Nonetheless, the material presented raises questions for exploration in further analysis, including the qualitative material generated in our own research.As noted in the study background, the international literature highlights a heightened risk of disadvantages for care-experienced adults in relation to a range of factors, including physical and mental health, security of housing, and education and employment.However, these risks function (and are mitigated or exacerbated) within wider frameworks of influence, including child welfare systems and the broader state provision, shaping the social, economic and cultural contexts of individual lives.The three countries chosen for this study represent two examples of the Nordic welfare model and one neoliberal welfare regime (cf.Esping-Andersen, e.g.1990).Unsurprisingly, there are more similarities between Denmark and Norway than with England, though there are of course variations among all three countries.At the risk of oversimplifying complex data sets, we can see from Eurostat data that the Nordic countries do better than England on most indicators of social disadvantage, and that they invest more in social protection for children and families.Participation in tertiary education is also funded to a higher level in both Denmark and Norway, whereas the public loan model in England means that young people graduate from university with considerable financial debts.
Language: English
Topic: Child Welfare and Adoption
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6987739385
