Weaving ‘social’ into LCA: a methodological comparison of Social Life Cycle Assessment with purely qualitative social sustainability assessment
Year: 2023
Type: dissertation
Abstract: quantities to monetary values-a process highly sensitive for error.Company specific data is needed to evaluate social flows for the direct-quantification method to reflect the specific company better, and the amount of hours workers work on the specific production process needs to be calculated frompreferably-company-specific data as well.Whereas the UNEP Guidelines provide a some guidance, expertise is required from a practitioner on performing an S-LCA.The process of understanding S-LCA, a social database, and understanding S-LCA terminology is a time consuming process. Company-specific Social Life Cycle Assessment -results and evaluationThrough SAM social performance of companies is assessed, further aggregated through the workerhours activity variable as product' social performance.Data is needed on policies, documentations of proof, as well as supplementing questionnaires and interviews.Different performance levels can be assigned through the scoring framework developed by Ramirez et al. (2014).As company-specific data is required and no generic data can be used, this requires and extensive data gathering process.However, as this is highly time consuming, certain processes and companies should be prioritized.For this study, the fashion brand, Tier 1 manufacturer and Tier 2 yarn supplier are assessed.Companyspecific performance is analyzed assessed on an A to D level on certain prioritized subcategories related to the stakeholder category 'workers'.Both the a prioritization of companies as well as subcategories for feasibility purposes lead to the assessment 's scope being narrowed down from the beginning on.The performance of the product is assessed for the stakeholder 'workers'.Here, a lower performance is identified on 'freedom of association and collective bargaining', 'fair salary' and 'working hours'.This performance is reflected through the Tier 1 manufacturer's performance as a company, because of its 86% contribution to the system in terms of labor hours.Results do not reflect the actual system where also several other companies (i.e., chemical, dyes and elastic suppliers, and transportation and distribution parties) are involved, excluded due to data unavailability.In terms of the Tier 1 manufacturer, performance can be improved on the mentioned aspects where lower performance is identified.Generally, however, the company is performing relatively well as compared to the local garment industry, where many more systemic changes should be implemented for bettering the sectorial social performance.The fashion brand performs well in terms of internal performance on all subcategories.Their supplier monitoring on the Tier 2 yarn supplier should, however, be evaluated to see whether more specific information can be found on this Tier 2 supplier.Currently, this stakeholder is not properly assessed due to data unavailability.In the case of this study-when only having assessed three companies-the life cycle identification of the product's social performance is not providing an added value over the company-performance identification.Through using the worker-hours variable as a scaling factor for amount of the labor hours each company is performing, the product's life cycle performance is set equal to the performance of the Tier 1 manufacturer, due to its predominant share in amount of labor-hours.Therefore, whereas the method does seem promising, it requires a very time consuming data gathering process on both the company aspect-as many companies should be included-and related to subcategories.In this assessment only the life cycle calculations for the stakeholder category 'workers' were assessed.vi Conclusion Relevant insights are obtained through conducting a purely qualitative social sustainability assessment, where no initial expertise is needed for.However, an extensive data-collection process lies at its basis: data should be gathered on the product's supply chain, company policies, as well as a general understanding of the company's management systems and supplier relationships is needed.The UNEP S-LCA Guidelines focus on product-S-LCA, which through aligning methodological uniformity with E-LCA comes with methodological issues:• Using an activity variable as worker-hours is not directly linked to social flows which are not related to labor activities as e.g., an illiteracy rate, but is currently used as a variable for these flows as well.This causes both redundant and incorrect information in life cycle calculations;• Social flows are not always causally linked to a specific product or the responsibility of an organization, but rather stem from higher-level issues related to the sector or country in which the organization or process operates.This is not adequately addressed in the Guidelines; Ultimately, it can be concluded that the qualitative nature of social impacts, and their relation to organizations involved is not sufficiently reflected through quantitatively relating social aspects to the function a product delivers.Bringing together the three pillars of sustainability for purposes of LCSA will lead to many inconsistencies between the three assessment methods.Due to the quantitative and qualitative difference in nature between environmental and social issues, reaching a full alignment between E-LCA and S-LCA for LCSA purposes is found to be unlikely.Reflected through its importance as identified in this study, the organizational aspect of social issues should be addressed in social sustainability assessments, going beyond the product-focus of the Guidelines.Other approaches to S-LCA through taking an organizational perspective-like SAM-, seem to be more fitting to the nature of social aspects.Still, the issue of using a quantitative activity variable to relate the performance of organizations to a specific product system causes some difficulties.However, comparing this approach to purely qualitative ways of assessing social sustainability, it does provide a link with a specific system and saying something about the social performance of a product can be of additional value for decision-making on one product over the other.A purely qualitative way of assessing social risks or performance does not provide this extra step, thereby staying at the level of company-level risks and performance-without being able to say anything about the product itself.Comparing SAM to the purely qualitative ways of assessing social sustainability, SAM does provide a link with a specific product system, whereas the Roadmap and IFC compliance assessments stay at company-level risks and performance.Addressing the social performance of a product can be of additional value for decision-making on one product over another.
Author: van Dulmen, Nina (author)
Language: English
Subfield: Environmental Engineering
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6988092179
