Work

Breach of Peace and Section 9-503 of the Uniform Commercial Code-A Modern Definition for an Ancient Restriction

Year: 1978
Type: article
Abstract: the debtor.'The only restriction on the self-help remedy is that it must be carried out without breach of the peace.Many provisions of the Code are of relatively recent origin, whereas the self-help remedy with its breach of peace restriction has evolved from a long historic process.The purpose of this comment is to assess how this historic evolution has culminated in a definition of breach of peace for section 9-503. II. Historical Background of the Self-Help Remedy A. From Anarchy to Abolition-Protection of the Debtor's Property Interest and the Interest of Society[In tracing the history of the self-help remedy] we must begin not with the right of law of distress, but with the disposition of impulse which naturally prompts an injured person to take from the wrongdoer, if he dare, whatever is seizable and transportable.Passing on from the impulse we come to the fact, then to the custom, and finally to the legal right of distraint.8 For many centuries the self-help remedy was tolerated, not because of a conscious weighing of policies, but as a result of the weakness of the legal institutions that control the self-help impulse.9 As legal institutions began to develop, the reaction against self-help grew until this remedy was abolished in toto by the time of the Norman Conquest.The reasons for the curtailment of self-help were a growing concern for the personal property interests of the one against whom the remedy was exercised and a reaction against the lawlessness that was apt to prevail when one was permitted to take the law into his own hands.' 0 In time, however, a third interest evolved that resurrected the self-help remedy. B. The Rebirth of Self-Help--Protection of the Creditor's Property InterestThe evolution of the feudal system brought about renewed interest in self-help remedies.This interest resulted from the need to have an 7. See Murdock v. Blake, 26 Utah 2d 22, 29, 484 P.2d 164, 169 (1971), in which the court held that "[tihe most important remedy available to a secured party is the right to take possession of the collateral following a debtor's default."(footnote omitted).When a creditor decides that repossession is necessary, the self-help remedy is beneficial since it prevents debtors from "skipping" with the collateral or inflicting greater than normal wear and tear.In addition, it provides a creditor with an expeditious return of the collateral before it can further depreciate and eliminates the necessity of expending court costs to regain possession.All of these "creditor" advantages benefit the specific debtor by decreasing the size of any deficiency judgment and consumers in general by making credit more readily available at lower costs.White, The Abolition of Self-Help Repossession: The Poor Pay Even More, [1973] Wis.L. REv.502, 522-23 [hereinafter cited as White]; Mentschikoff, Peaceful Repossession Under the Uniform Commercial Code: A Constitutional and Economic Analysis, 14 WM.& MARY L. REV.767, 772, 779 (1973) [hereinafter cited as Mentschikoff]; Johnson, Denial of Self-Help Repossession: An Economic Analysis, 47 S. CAL.L. REV.82, 90-107 (1973) [hereinafter cited as Johnson].8. 3 T.
Author: Mikolajczyk, Eugene
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6989676310
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10