Work

Coördinatie in de Belgische appel- en perensector: Een onderzoek naar risicobeheer, collectieve actie, en meerwaardecreatie

Year: 2022
Type: dissertation
Abstract: EU policy increasingly foresees a role for institutional arrangements in providing a fair standard of living to farmers. This thesis aims to advance understanding of how institutional arrangements contribute to this objective. In particular, we explore how institutional arrangements contribute to risk management, cooperation, and value creation by farmers. In four empirical research chapters, we discuss the strengths and weaknesses of specific institutional arrangements for the reduction of price risk exposure, the access to financial derivatives, the collective marketing, and the creation of value by apple and pear growers. First, we explore the relationship between apple and pear growers' storage decisions and risk management. We examine whether storage is used as a risk management or rather as a speculation tool, and how this relates to the uptake of institutional arrangements for price risk management. We find that most growers do not participate in price pooling or harvest sales, despite the ability of these arrangements to reduce price risk exposure. Second, we discuss the development of a new institutional arrangement enabling pear growers to use financial derivatives. Belgian pear growers, as most F&V growers, were previously unable to use financial derivatives as a risk management strategy. The Fruit Trading Company pioneered with the establishment of a platform for price swap contracting between growers and traders. Moreover, the platform differs from pre-existing price swap contracts in agriculture by allowing growers and traders to enter price swaps anonymously, and without counterparty risk. By discussing the development of this unique arrangement, we aim to demonstrate the untapped potential of price swap contracts in agriculture. Third, we examine how the economic performance of Belgian apple and pear cooperatives is related to members' satisfaction with their voice in the cooperatives' decisions. We assess how satisfaction with voice influences members' trust in cooperatives, and how trust in turn influences their willingness to delegate decisions to the cooperative management. This willingness to delegate decisions has an impact on economic performance, by affecting cooperatives' ability to coordinate quality and supply. By uncovering this relationship, we demonstrate the importance of good democratic governance for the performance of cooperatives. Fourth, we explore how the introduction of branded fruit varieties has allowed Belgian apple and pear growers to upgrade quality and to create value. Following a reform of intellectual property rights on plant varieties, 'clubs' of fruit breeders, producers, and wholesalers have introduced such branded varieties in Belgium. We find that brand ownership at the level of the club translates into authority of wholesalers over the process of quality control, due to the exclusive licenses awarded to wholesalers for distributing the branded variety. The establishment of authority has enabled wholesalers to enforce quality requirements, whereas this enforcement was incomplete at best in pre-existing supply chains. As a result, branded varieties receive price premiums, and the different partners in the club create value. Growers' autonomy, however, reduces in this arrangement. The more general conclusion of this thesis is thus that institutional arrangements in the Belgian apple and pear sector need to find a balance between the autonomy of growers and the efficiency with which quality control and supply are coordinated.
Source: Lirias
Institution: KU Leuven
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6990123563
Cites: 313
Cited by:
Related to: 10