Work

A Comparative Study on the Effectiveness of Written Corrective Feedback in Improving Indonesian and Japanese Students' Writing Achievement

Type: dissertation
Abstract: Introduction 1.1 Purposes and Background of the StudyThis study is examined the effectiveness of Written Corrective Feedback (WCF) sources (teacher, peer, and self) in the English as a Foreign Language (EFL) area, especially for senior high school students in Indonesia and Japan.Besides, this study will also explore the beliefs on WCF from teachers' and students' points of view.Thus, their points of view need to be researched to avoid the students failing to understand the feedback given and do the correct revision.As we know, among four basic skills in learning English, writing is considered the least important to be taught, since it seems very challenging and time-consuming, especially dealing with checking and providing feedback.Thus, writing is considered as the most challenging skill for learners to master (Richards & Renandya, 2002).Tillema (2012) said that writing is one of the most important educational success skills, even though it is one of the most challenging skills to be learned.Being able to write has been considered as an essential language skill for English language learning.As stated in the Senior High School Curriculum (Kemendikbud, 2013), Indonesian students must have skills in compiling and understanding the meaning of oral and written texts, using text structures in order and coherently as well as linguistic elements accurately, acceptably, and fluently.According to Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science, and Technology (MEXT, 2018) in Japan, it is stated that students need to be able to write and convey information, thoughts, and feelings about everyday topics using basic words and sentences, paying attention to logic, if lots of support is utilized in terms of the words and sentences used and prior preparation, and to be able to write and convey information, thoughts, and feelings about social topics using basic words, phrases, and sentences based on what they have heard and read, paying attention to logic, lots of support are utilized in terms of words, phrases, and sentences to use and preparation in advance.Nunan (2001) says that writing is the process of thinking to invent ideas and organize them into various written forms.Additionally, learning writing entails basic familiarity with higher-level subskills of planning and organizing and lower subskills of spelling, word choice, and mechanics (Richards & Renandya, 2002).Many years, researchers have examined the effects of different types of CF (Corrective Feedback) on adult L2 writers with results that do not fundamentally agree with one another.Truscott (1996), who started the debate, found it to be enormously ineffective and even in some cases harmful to do CF, on the other hand, Ferris (1999) claimed that CF is very recommendable and should, therefore, have a place in L2 writing classes.Still, what is stated about CF for adult L2 learners, mostly in university area does not necessarily apply to high school students, especially in Indonesia and Japan.From the point of view of teachers and students are also needed to be deeply researched.As we know that the gap between teachers and students can be minimized if we know what both really want about WCF.Teachers' and students' beliefs can affect the teaching strategy that applied by the teachers in the classroom.Recent studies on L2 and EFL WCF have found that students usually cannot assess or check their own writings, even though writing guidance is provided.This condition is partly because the students have never been in the teachers' position.Therefore, many students are unable to precisely assess their own writing products (Bjork, 1999).As a result, giving WCF is not only correcting students' errors, but it should also give information for teachers and students, provide students with advice about learning, language input, a form of motivation, and lead students toward autonomy.Thus, this study's results are expected to give a valuable contribution to the EFL researchers, who intend to do some researches in English writing, especially in the WCF area.In one case, it is expected to be beneficial for future researchers in WCF area as their guide.Since this study is focused
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6990127163
Cites: 50
Cited by:
Related to: 10