Work

Dimensions of Conspiracy : An inquiry into the cognitive and epistemic standing of conspiracy theories

Year: 2025
Type: book
Abstract: This doctoral thesis investigates the conceptual, epistemological, andpsychological dimensions of conspiracy theories, aiming to develop a more preciseand philosophically rigorous framework for understanding and evaluating them.The work is structured around five original papers that address key questions:What constitutes a conspiracy theory? Are such theories inherently irrational?How should we conceptualize their epistemic status in light of expert testimony,trust, and cognitive psychology?The thesis begins by examining the contested nature of the term conspiracytheory, revealing the limitations of both pejorative and overly broad definitions.It engages with the philosophical debate between generalism and particularism,arguing for a neutral, theoretically useful definition based on Carnapianconceptual engineering. It then explores whether belief in conspiracy theories canbe rational, with attention to decision-theoretic considerations and the epistemicrole of experts. The final chapter investigates why individuals come to endorseconspiracy theories, evaluating claims that such beliefs are primarily driven byirrationality, cognitive biases, or social belonging.A central contribution is the development of the Dimensions framework—adescriptive tool for analysing conspiracy theories not solely in terms of truth orfalsity, but with attention to the contexts, motivations, and epistemic normssurrounding their adoption. This framework enables a more nuancedunderstanding of conspiracy theories as complex social phenomena. Bycombining conceptual analysis, epistemological evaluation, and psychologicalinsight, the thesis offers a comprehensive and interdisciplinary approach thatcontributes to ongoing debates in conspiracy theory theory—the academic studyof conspiracy theories—as well as to social epistemology more broadly.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6990513523
FWCI:
Cites: 202
Cited by:
Related to: 10