Year: 2021
Type: dissertation
Abstract: ABSTRACT - Introduction: Early adolescent substance use is a public mental health problem. Risk behaviours that start early in life have enduring negative effects throughout life. Effective policies and interventions on adolescent substance use must tackle its antecedents from developmental and systemic perspectives. Emotional and behavioural (EB) symptoms develop early in life and have been associated with substance use and other risk behaviours. However, the complex interplay between EB symptoms throughout development and risk behaviours in early adolescence remains elusive. This dissertation aims to (1) identify empirically derived patterns of substance use in early adolescence and associated antisocial behaviours and gender differences; (2) study the evolution of EB symptoms from early childhood to early adolescence; and (3) explore the association between EB profiles and trajectories, and substance use patterns. Methods: Firstly, using the Portuguese sample of 15-year-old adolescents from the 2010 ‘Health Behavior in School-Aged Children’ (HBSC) cross-sectional survey, we identified patterns of substance use and initiation and its associated factors by latent class regression analysis. Secondly, using the UK Millennium Cohort Study (MCS), we identified EB profiles and their transitions from early childhood to early adolescence by latent profile transition analysis. Thirdly, also using data from the MCS, we identified trajectories of EB symptoms by parallel process growth mixture modelling and explored their association with substance use and antisocial behaviours patterns in adolescence derived by latent class analysis. Results: In the stratified by gender analysis of the Portuguese HBSC data, we identified three common classes for both genders, specifically, ‘non-users’ (boys [B] 34.42%, girls [G] 26.79%), ‘alcohol experimenters’ (B 38.79%, G 43.98%) and ‘alcohol and tobacco frequent users’ (B 21.31%, G 10.36%), with two additional unique classes: ‘alcohol experimenters and tobacco users’ in girls (18.87%), and ‘early initiation and poly-substance users’ in boys (5.48%). Using UK’s MCS data, we found four classes of adolescent substance use and antisocial behaviours: ‘normative’ (71.8%), ‘alcohol and physical fighting’ (15.3%), ‘alcohol and tobacco’ (9.9%), ‘poly-substance use and antisocial behaviours’ (3%). Boys were more likely than girls to belong to the ‘poly-substance use’ profile, while girls were more likely to belong to the ‘alcohol and tobacco’ profile. In the British cohort, applying latent profile and latent transition analysis, we found that the number and specific profiles of EB symptoms changed with the developmental stage. We found a higher number of profiles for ages 3, 5, and 14, suggesting greater heterogeneity in the presentation of EB symptoms in early childhood and adolescence compared to late childhood. There was greater heterotypic continuity between ages 3 and 5, particularly in transitions from higher to lower severity profiles. Applying growth mixture modelling, we found five trajectories of EB symptoms throughout development: ‘low symptoms’ (73.5%), ‘moderate externalising’ (8.9%), ‘moderate externalising and internalising (childhood limited)’ (7.1%), ‘increasing internalising’ (8.0%), and ‘high externalising and internalising’ (2.6%). Severe externalising symptoms were typically comorbid with internalising symptoms. Children exposed to socioeconomic disadvantages were more likely to belong or transition to any moderate or high EB symptoms profiles. Maternal psychological distress was associated with internalising profiles while harsh parenting was associated with externalising profiles. Children from mothers with high professional qualifications were less likely to belong or transition to any moderate or high EB profile at any age but especially in early childhood. Moderate to severe externalising symptoms across development were a vulnerability to early adolescent substance use, even when these symptoms were restricted to early childhood. Children and adolescents in the ‘high externalising and internalising’ and ‘moderate externalising’ trajectories were more likely to belong to any problematic behaviour class, especially the ‘poly-substance use and antisocial behaviours’ class (Odds Ratio [OR]: 5.11, Confidence Interval [CI]: 2.61-9.99; OR: 4.83, CI: 3.17-7.35; respectively). Inclusion in the ‘moderate externalising and internalising (childhood limited)’ class was associated with higher odds of belonging to the ‘alcohol and tobacco’ class (OR: 1.50, CI: 1.05-2.14). For internalising symptoms, the trajectory ‘increasing internalising’ starting in early childhood was not associated with adolescent substance use. However, the ‘high internalising’ profile at age 14 was associated with binge drinking (OR: 1.43, CI: 1.04-1.97), tobacco use (OR: 2.06. CI:1.60-2.66) and cannabis use (OR: 2.51, CI: 1.65-3.81), while children in moderate internalising profiles were less likely to report alcohol use in adolescence (age 11 ‘moderate internalising’ OR: 0.77, CI: 0.66-0.90). Conclusion: Early adolescent substance use is not an isolated phenomenon. It co-occurs with other risk behaviours, and the simultaneous use of multiple substances is the rule rather than the exception. In this way, interventions to be effective must tackle not only substance use but also other risk behaviours that co-occur frequently. Chronification of emotional and behavioural symptoms has enduring effects throughout development with higher rates of early adolescent substance use, warranting the need to treat developmental psychopathology as early as possible. Concordant with the existing literature, externalising symptoms were a vulnerability to early adolescent substance use. However, we found that even moderate levels of externalising symptoms or limited to childhood were associated with early adolescent substance use. While internalising profiles from early childhood to preadolescence were associated with a lower risk of adolescent substance use, severe internalising symptoms in adolescence were associated with a higher risk of substance use. These results may explain the mixed findings reported in the literature on the association between internalising symptoms and adolescent substance use. Emotional and behavioural symptoms are thus fundamental developmental antecedents of early adolescent substance use. Treating and preventing emotional and behavioural symptoms early, with developmentally sensitive and systemic oriented interventions is paramount to tackle early adolescent substance use.
Institution: Universidade Nova de Lisboa
Language: English
Subfield: Epidemiology
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6990925389
