Work

Generic to Xeric: Shaping Public Opinion and Perceptions of Urban Landscapes in Dryland Environments

Year: 2023
Type: article
Study design: Clinical Trial
Abstract: In drylands urban environments, landscape architects face challenges in designing urban green spaces that balance public usage, opinion, and ecosystem services. The conventional wisdom and opinions of the general public/users on landscape aesthetics and design practices often contradict sustainable ecosystem services offered by non-traditional landscape designs. This problem affects both public satisfaction with urban green spaces and human and ecological health. Literature related to biodiversity in the urban context, dryland environmental challenges, use of Virtual Reality (VR) in landscape perception is reviewed. Gaps in relevant research are identified as well as opportunities to push research in this subject into new, underexplored areas. To address this challenge, an experimental research study was performed with a control group and experimental group. The experimental group received an Educational Intervention (EI) while the control group did not. Both groups are subjected to a VR experience of twelve different landscapes, varying in contextual settings and landscape treatments, while attached to biometric sensors. All participants received visual and audio stimuli to acquire both subjective and physiological reactions to a range of VR landscape designs. Results suggest that EI may have been successful in shifting sentiments toward alternative landscape treatments. Results show consistent trends in EI shifting perceptions of positive aspects of alternative landscape methods in areas of “maintenance free”, “biodiversity”, “environmentally friendly”, and “natural”. The experimental EI group showed a statistically significant change in preferences, showing less desirability for traditional lawns, and increased positive sentiment toward alternative landscape treatments such as Xeriscape and prairie-like conditions. Heat map results showed consistency between both control and experimental groups that there is a preference for large vegetation that provides shade and shelter, with negative preferences towards areas with excessive undifferentiated space. Biometric data, while inconclusive at the group level, showed interesting spikes and blips in data for individual participants. Using the data collected from the public opinion surveys, observation of users’ physiological reactions to the designed spaces, and existing literature on appropriate plant species, a more informed approach to designing urban spaces in dryland climates can be achieved. This more informed approach can facilitate improved outcomes for both the human needs and conservation imperatives, leading to increased sustainability in dryland urban environments.
Author: Farrow, Jonathan G.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6991307218
FWCI:
Cites: 44
Cited by:
Related to: 10