Impact of Childhood Trauma on Levels of Depressive Symptoms, Pain, Functionality, and Cognitive Conflicts in Fibromyalgia
Year: 2023
Type: dissertation
Abstract: [eng] In recent years, much scientific evidence has shown the role of child maltreatment in human development, which impacts all aspects of growth, physical, behavioral, emotional, and cognitive. Depending on the extent of the maltreatment, it may lead to childhood trauma and generate a vulnerability to mental and physical health. The extent of the maltreatment encompasses its frequency and duration, the age in which it occurred, and the type of maltreatment, whether one isolated type or several types of maltreatment. When more than one type of maltreatment is present, it produces a cumulative effect that can be potentially more damaging than a single type of maltreatment. Although little is known to date, many studies focus on uncovering the role and influence of childhood trauma in chronic pain. Moreover, even less is known about the role of specific types of maltreatment experienced in childhood or the cumulative effect of multiple maltreatment types on the treatment outcome of patients with chronic pain. This research investigated the impact of single types of childhood trauma and the cumulative effect of more than one type of maltreatment on reported levels of depressive symptoms, pain, functionality, and indexes of cognitive conflict before and after psychological treatment for participants with Fibromyalgia (FM) and depressive symptoms. The research was divided into two studies, Study 1 was a cross-sectional analysis, and Study 2 included pre and posttreatment data analysis. For these two studies, 104 women with FM and depressive symptoms responded to the childhood trauma questionnaire at baseline assessment. In Study 1, our sample was assessed for single and cumulative types of maltreatment using a cutoff indicative of traumatic levels and compared with similar samples from other studies. In addition, childhood trauma scores were compared with scores of depressive symptoms, pain, functionality, and cognitive conflicts at pretreatment (baseline). Results revealed that our sample had considerably higher percentages of participants with childhood trauma in at least four maltreatment dimensions than community samples of other studies. Regarding the hypotheses predicting possible correlations between depressive symptoms, pain, functionality, and cognitive conflicts with rates of childhood trauma, for both single and cumulative maltreatment types, there was only one small-sized correlation indicating a tendency of those women with FM to display low levels of functionality in the presence of a history of childhood emotional abuse. In Study 2, participants were treated with either cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) or personal construct therapy (PCT). There was minimal difference between the treatment outcomes of those two therapies, and for this reason, this investigation considered the two groups as one sample. The change index of depressive symptoms, pain levels, functionality, and cognitive conflicts at posttreatment scores was calculated and compared to childhood trauma scores at baseline. In addition, childhood trauma scores and dropouts were analyzed to identify a potential correlation between these two variables. Results of Study 2 showed that participants with a history of sexual or emotional abuse had an improvement in pain levels at discharge, based on a small size correlation between the change index of pain levels and sexual abuse, and a medium size correlation between the same change index and emotional abuse, suggesting that such a history of CT may impact pain levels in FM. One medium and one small size correlation showed less change in the discrepancy of selfconstructions related, respectively, to the items “self” and “ideal self” when participants had a history of emotional abuse and “ideal self” and “others” when they had a history of emotional neglect. These negative correlations may indicate a tendency that a history of emotional abuse and neglect might be a handicap to accessing positive therapy outcomes in terms of a positive view of oneself and perceived similarity to others. There was one significant positive correlation between the change index of the number of IDs and physical neglect, and one medium size correlation between that same index and emotional neglect. These results might indicate that the impact of childhood neglect lost its strength following therapy, perhaps because of an acceptance of new possibilities for understanding conflicts. Lastly, the change index of the discrepancy between the “ideal self” and “others” showed a significant negative correlation with five and three types of cumulative maltreatment, suggesting that a cumulative history of CT may affect access to positive therapy outcomes regarding a critical view of others. In addition, one type and absence of maltreatment also showed a medium size negative correlation for this same change index. No other correlations were found for the indexes of change. Furthermore, there was no correlation between single or cumulative childhood trauma and dropouts. By exploring the possible impact of childhood trauma on depressive symptoms, pain, functionality, and cognitive conflicts in FM with depressive symptoms, this study intended to generate knowledge to inform psychological treatments and strategies to enhance treatment outcomes.
Author: Ribeiro, Anita Julieta
Institution: Universitat de Barcelona
Language: English
Topic: Child Abuse and Trauma
Subfield: Clinical Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6991807369
