Year: 2011
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Chronic pain of non-malignant origin is a long-lasting condition, often requiring long-term medication intake. The aim of this doctoral research was to study the prevalence and determinants of medication non-adherence, both under- and overuse, and to investigate the impact of medication non-adherence on pain intensity, interference of pain in daily activities, the perceived physical and mental health status and patient satisfaction with pain treatment.Medication adherence in chronic non-malignant pain populations is not well studied. Our systematic review indicated that non-adherence with pain medication varies between 8% and 53%. Yet, the limited number of studies are characterized by numerous methodological problems, i.e. 1)the lack of a conceptual and operational definition of adherence, 2)the absence of a clear distinction between medication underuse, overuse or abuse, 3)the use of less reliable measurement methods, 4) a rather small sample sizes and 5) no differentiation in type of pain medication being assessed. Due to these methodological problems, it is difficult to make firm conclusions on the prevalence and determinants of medication non-adherence in patients with chronic non malignant pain. Knowledge on determinants is needed to define risk profiles and to guide successful interventions. Finally, only a few studies investigated the impact of medication non-adherence on clinical outcome in this population, which again suffered from methodological problems.First, we investigated the prevalence of medication non-adherence. Half of our patients deviated from the prescribed pharmacological treatment. More specifically, 48% percent of the patients included in a single center cross-sectional study (chapter 3) and 62% of a multi-center sample (chapter 4) did not perfectly follow the prescribed medication regimen of the pain center. Our study added to the existing literature, by examining both underuse and overuse of pain medication within the same patient sample. Medication underuse in patients with chronic non-malignant pain ranges between 32% (single center study; chapter 3) and 40% (multicenter study; chapter 4). Fourteen percent of the patients, both in our single center (chapter 3) and multicenter study (chapter 4), were using more medication than prescribed. Our second aim was to study the potential determinants of both medication underuse and overuse non-adherence in patients with chronic non-malignant pain, using all dimensions described in the World Health Organization framework. This WHO framework describes adherence to long-term therapies as a multi-dimensional phenomenon, influenced by the interplay of five interacting factors: socio-economic factors, therapy related factors, patient related factors, condition related factors and health care team / system related factors. In a multicenter, cross-sectional study among 265 chronic pain patients, we found that only 38% of the patients were perfectly adherent. Based on multivariable analyses, underuse was significantly associated with more prescribed analgesics, self medication, lower pain intensity, and lack of information. Overuse of medication was associated with more prescribed analgesics and current smoking. Our results show that the set of determinants of non-adherence, proposed by the WHO is suitable to study drivers of underuse, but that the framework is less suitable to study determinants of medication overuse. Thus, in future research and clinical practice, differentiating between these two types of medication non-adherence is warranted, because a different set of variables influence underuse and overuse.Finally, we selected five outcome parameters, that are considered to be important subjective endpoints for patients with chronic pain. We studied prospectively the evolution of pain intensity, the interference of pain on daily activities, physical and mental functioning and patient satisfaction with their pain treatment over a period of nine months and investigated whether medication non-adherence had a significant impact on this evolution. In our study, we could not find a significant impact of medication non-adherence on the evolution of these selected outcome parameters. However, patient satisfaction with pain treatment improved over time, especially in adherent patients.While more research is needed to refine the assessment methods of adherence, the risk profile of underusers and overusers, and the drivers of these medication taking behaviors, we recommend health care professionals paying more attention to medication underuse and overuse. Only with good mutual communication on medication taking behavior, the efficacy of pain treatment can be properly evaluated and improved.
Source: Lirias (KU Leuven)
Author: Broekmans, Susan
Language: English
Subfield: Family Practice
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Keywords: medication adherence, chronic non-cancer pain, medication underuse, medication overuse, analgesics, predictors of adherence, pain intensity, pain interference, physical and mental health, patient satisfaction, pain management, long-term treatment, opioids, benzodiazepines, antidepressants, antiepileptic drugs
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6992586171
