Work

!1! Looks Non-transitive!

Type: article
Abstract: Suppose you are presented with three red objects. You are then asked to take a careful look at each possible pair of objects, and to decide whether or not their members look chromatically the same. You carry out the instructions thoroughly, and the following propositions sum up the results of your empirical investigation: i. red object #1 looks the same in colour as red object #2. ii. red object #2 looks the same in colour as red object #3. iii. red object #1 does not look the same in colour as red object #3. Experiences like these may seem familiar. Had you recently been in a hardware shop to choose a suitable shade of beige for repainting your kitchen wall, you might have experienced something similar. The shades of beige on two colour chips are indiscriminable. Yet, when you compare them with a third colour chip, while the latter is indiscriminable from the shade on the second chip, it is discriminable from the first.1 Such experiences suggest that the relation denoted by the predicate looks the same as isn’t transitive. That is, the following thesis is not true of looks the same as:
Authors: Philippe Chuard, Richard Corry
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6992614003
Cites: 13
Cited by:
Related to: 10