Maize, Beans, and the New Green Revolution: Opening the Black Box of “Feed the Future” Food Security Projects in Guatemala
Year: 2023
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Critical agri-food scholarship and recent high-profile events, like the 2022 UN Food Summit, demonstrate the oppositional relationship between food security and food sovereignty, and between social movement actors and state-based international development agencies. Critical agri-food scholars have shown how many international development efforts toward food security are neoliberally influenced and antithetical to food sovereignty; they foster dependency on agrichemicals and biotechnology and thus constitute a ‘New Green Revolution’. However, despite this fact, there is some evidence that agricultural development, global nutrition practices, and ‘food security’ efforts more generally may be shifting in more complex ways, adopting more socially and ecologically responsive actions. In this study, I focus on the spatially specific ways food security ideas and policies get worked out, refracted, and constituted in practice. I take an ethnographic approach to investigate one such ‘in-between’ space—USAID’s “Feed the Future” (FtF) program in Guatemala—where dynamics between competing ideas about food insecurity and hunger play out with greater complexity, interaction, and dynamism than is typically conveyed in scholarship critical of food security. I ask: How do some FtF project activities come to emulate activities more in line with anti-neoliberal food sovereignty and agroecology social movements? What conditions and social forces helped facilitate their emergence? How are these activities rationalized within a market-based framework? Using a critical ethnographic approach, I draw on 65 interviews, four months of fieldwork in the Western Highlands of Guatemala, and textual analysis of program descriptions, reports, and international aid records, I argue that FtF food security projects are ‘authorless strategies’ Ferguson 1994:20). I show how hard-to-categorize FtF projects in Guatemala are assembled from heterogeneous parts including the agency of individual actors, interactions between diverse social groups, global development agendas, discourses, and the material conditions of life in Guatemala. While FtF is reflective of the neoliberal structures that produce typical food security projects, FtF projects cannot be reduced to a masterplan. By reframing FtF practices as contingent, temporary, and fragile, I underscore the ability of individuals and groups of actors to reshape food security at various levels and demonstrate the possibility of detaching food security practices from the market-based goals of neoliberally influenced food security projects like FtF.
Author: Seay-Fleming, Carrie
Language: English
Subfield: Development
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDGs: Zero hunger, No poverty
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6992617207
