Measurement and improvement of medication adherence in chronic disease populations: The case of electronic monitoring in solid organ transplant patients
Year: 2011
Type: dissertation
Abstract: 1. BackgroundSurvival after transplantation has improved significantly over the past decades. Although adherence to drug treatment is crucial to prevent disease progression and additional morbidity in view of rejection and graft loss, 20% to 28% of organ transplant recipients are non-adherent to their immunosuppressive regimen. Recently published systematic reviews demonstrated that an estimated 50% (range: 20%-73%) of late acute rejections and 15% (range: 3%-35%) of graft losses are associated with non-adherence. Given the impact of non-adherence on poor clinical outcomes in transplantation, urgent actions need to be taken to decrease non-adherence. Until now, no systematic review on the efficacy of adherence-enhancing interventions in transplantation had been carried out. Therefore, it is difficult to understand which interventions are most successful in reducing non-adherence in transplant patients. In addition, an important drawback in numerous published studies is the lack of an adequate measurement method to identify medication non-adherence. The use of an accurate and sensitive measurement method is important to detect non-adherent patients before adherence-enhancing interventions can be implemented. In absence of a golden standard to measure medication non-adherence consideration should be given to assessing non-adherence using a combination of methods, rather than using one method. This triangulation method has been advised by the Non-Adherence Consensus Conference Summary Report. To date, electronic monitoring (EM) is considered to be the most sensitive method for measuring medication non-adherence. Recently, the Helping Hand was launched by Bang & Olufsen-Medicom, Denmark. The Helping Hand has the appearance of a slightly curved handset, consisting of a flat holder for blister packages. As a prerequisite to their application in clinical studies or daily practice, the performance of electronic monitoring devices should be tested. To guide a formal testing of this new electronic monitoring device, we have built a conceptual framework consisting of an objective and a subjective dimension. The objective dimension refers to validity, and encompasses reliability on the one hand (accuracy and precision) and internal and external validity on the other hand. The subjective dimension describes the users perspective on usability with the sub-dimensions of user performance, satisfaction and acceptability. Based on this information we aimed to evaluate 1) interventions (including electronic monitoring) that have been tested to improve medication adherence in transplant patients and the efficacy of the interventions identified ; 2) the reliability of the Helping Hand and the Medication Electronic Monitoring System (MEMS); 3) the usability of the Helping Hand by kidney transplant patients and healthy volunteers; and 4) the prevalence of medication non-adherence for immunosuppressants and co-medication in heart, liver and lung transplant patients using different measurement methods.2. MethodsFirst, we conducted a systematic literature review by using CINAHL, MEDLINE and PsycINFO. Study inclusion criteria were: testing an intervention aimed to enhance adherence with immunosuppressive medication in organ transplantation, including a measurable adherence outcome. The methodological quality of the studies was checked using the CONSORT and EPOC guidelines. Second, in a prospective sequential descriptive laboratory study, the reliability of 25 Helping Hand (10 without and 15 with reminder system) and 50 MEMS devices (25 with 18-month and 25 with 2-year battery life) was tested. The devices were manipulated twice daily at varying time points following a predefined protocol during 3 consecutive weeks (i.e. 42 manipulations/device). Accuracy, using the fixed manipulation scheme as the reference, was calculated as the percentage of missed events, overregistrations and EM devices functioning 100% correctly. Third, we used a mixed-method (2-phase concurrent triangulation) design to evaluate the subjective dimension (the user performance, satisfaction and acceptability) of the Helping Hand. We studied a purposive sample of 11 kidney transplant patients and 10 healthy volunteers. Baseline performance was evaluated using think-aloud methodology and a 10-point Likert scale. After 3 weeks of Helping Hand use, satisfaction and acceptability were assessed using semi-structured interviews and 5-point Likert scales. Median scores were calculated for the total group, volunteers and kidney transplant patients. Qualitative content analysis identified usability dimensions. In the fourth study, the Helping Hand was used as an electronic monitoring device to measure the prevalence of medication non-adherence in heart, liver and lung transplant patients. Using a descriptive, longitudinal, comparative design, we included a convenience sample of adult heart (n=79), liver (n=56), and lung (n=104) transplant patients. Non-adherence with immunosuppressants was measured at inclusion (T0) and after three months (T1) using self-report (Basel Assessment of Adherence with Medication Scale (BAASIS)), collateral report (physician and nurse), blood assay and Electronic Monitoring. Non-adherence with co-medication was measured using the BAASIS. Besides, two Composite Adherence Scores (CAS-1,-2), which combined various methods of non-adherence assessment, were calculated. The level of adherence according to the different measurement methods was compared among the three organ groups using a KruskalWallis test for continuous data or chi-square test for nominal level data. Changes of adherence over time were calculated by a McNemars test for nominal variables (e.g. the BAASIS algorithm, collateral report and assay). Four EM parameters were calculated: 1) taking adherence; 2) dosing adherence; 3) timing adherence; and 4) the number of drug holidays.3. ResultsConcerning the literature review, twelve studies, focusing on renal, heart, and liver transplant recipients, were included. Five reports used an RCT design. Sample sizes varied between 18 and 110 subjects. CONSORT scores ranged from 3 to 18 out of 22 (median: 6.5). The EPOC scores ranged between 9 and 21 out of 23 (median: 15). The interventions were difficult to evaluate due to brief descriptions of intervention details. Five studies found a statistically significant improvement in adherence outcome after the intervention. Generally, most included a combination of patient-focused cognitive/educational, counseling/behavioral, and psychological/affective dimensions. Three publications used electronic monitoring as adherence enhancing intervention. Eight studies intervened at the healthcare provider, healthcare setting or healthcare system level, but showed a limited improvement in adherence.The results of the reliability study can be described as following: There were 5/420 (1.20%) and 1/630 (0.16%) missing registrations for Helping Hand without and with reminder respectively. Overregistrations were recorded in 2/420 (0.48%) Helping Hand without reminder and in 1/630 (0.16%) Helping Hand with reminder. There were 33/1050 (3.14%) missing registrations for MEMS with 18-months battery life, but no missing registrations for MEMS with 2-year battery life. No overregistrations occurred in MEMS. Perfect functioning was observed in 7/10 (70%) of the Helping Hand without and 13/15 (87%) of the Helping Hand with reminder, 5 (20.00%) MEMS with 18-months battery life, and 25 (100.0%) with 2-year battery life respectively. Third, we found the following results concerning the usability study of the Helping Hand: the devices intended use facilitating, reinforcing and monitoring a medication routine was received positively by all subjects. Likewise, the devices reporting function, which allows physicians to check users medication behavior, was scored positively by all patients except one. However, some obstacles should be taken into account. 1) All subjects considered the reminder tone difficult to hear. 2) Four found the feedback light too dim. 3) Five had difficulty interpreting the feedback function. 4) Eleven experienced difficulties loading and unloading medication. In view of the satisfaction dimension, there was a broad variation. On a 5-point Likert scale, 2 subjects scored 1 (not satisfied at all), while four scored 5 (very satisfied). Concerning acceptability, 12 subjects would recommend this device to others; only 8 of them envisioned its future use. Fourth, the prevalence of non-adherence for IS ranged from 23.8% (collateral report physician, T0) to 70.0% (CAS-2) in the overall sample. Concerning co-medication the overall non-adherence rate was 30.1% using the BAASIS. Non-adherence rates remained stable over time. At inclusion, significant NA differences between organ groups were reported by the BAASIS scale and the collateral report; lung transplant patients were less adherent to IS than heart or liver transplant recipients, and showed more non-adherence to co-medication. 4. Discussion & ConclusionFirst, this systematic review revealed that limited intervention research exists in the Tx literature, and that the majority of twelve existing studies showed major shortcomings, related to the methodology and the content of the interventions used. No single intervention proved to be superior at increasing adherence in organ transplantation, but combining interventions such as EM in a team approach for the chronic disease management of organ transplant patients may be effective in the long term. Second, battery life plays a role in MEMS, with a 2-year battery life increasing accuracy. For the Helping Hand, infrequent missing and overregistrations occur and therefore further technical improvements to enhance accuracy are needed. Third, although testing showed positive usability aspects of the Helping Hand, several issues need to be remedied, such as the weak sound signal, the
Source: Lirias
Author: De Bleser, Leentje
Institution: KU Leuven
Language: English
Subfield: Family Practice
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Keywords: medication adherence, electronic medication monitoring, solid organ transplant recipients, immunosuppressive therapy, helping hand, adherence measurement, adherence interventions, kidney transplantation, device usability, chronic disease management, medication non-adherence, patient education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6992682695
