A matter of time: Mechanisms behind fair treatment perceptions in temporary employment
Year: 2008
Type: dissertation
Abstract: According to Lepak and Snell (1999), strategies to externalise workers result from the low value and the low level of uniqueness of the human capital that is ascribed to these workers.This position holds in situations that require generic human capital that is of limited strategic value, and in which the firm's competitive position is not threatened.Organisations that follow this strategy should critically evaluate investing in training or development activities for their temporary employees.More recently, policy makers have begun to address the position of temporary workers more thoroughly.In 1999, the European Commission issued a directive 2 prescribing equal treatment of fixed-term employees compared to their permanent colleagues.In 2002, this directive was adapted into a Dutch law, the "Wet Gelijke Behandeling Tijdelijke en Vaste Medewerkers".This law prohibits unequal treatment of fixed-term workers with respect to employment conditions when compared to permanent workers who perform the same or similar work or function, taking qualifications and skills into account.Differences regarding employment conditions of fixed-term employees and permanent employees are only justified on the basis of objective reasons such as seniority.An ECdirective prescribing equal treatment of temporary agency workers 3 is still in process, primarily because the social partners are not able to come to consensus on objective grounds to justify unequal treatment (Zappala, 2003). Research problemDespite these legislative efforts, there exists a wide body of recent research on differences between temporary workers and permanent workers regarding the allocation of various employment benefits.These include salary (Balducci, Crivellini, Gallegati, Niccoli, & Zazzaro, 2006;Brown & Sessions, 2003;Dekker, 2007;Sels, Forrier, De Witte, Vander Steene, & Van Hootegem, 2002), secondary employment benefits (Ditsler, Fisher, & Gordon, 2005;Zeytinoglu & Cooke, 2005), and training and career opportunities (Connell & Burgess, 2006;Finegold, Levenson, & Van Buren, 2005;Forrier & Sels, 2003;Wallette, 2005).With a few exceptions (Bergström & Storrie, 2003), these studies find that temporary workers are to a lesser or larger extent disadvantaged as compared to their permanent colleagues.Moreover, this appears to be a trend that transcends geographical borders, as discrepancies are structurally found in the US (Kalleberg, 2000), Australia (Draca & Green, 2004), India (Bhandari & Heshmati, 2006), and Europe (Nienhuser & Matiaske, 2006).Furthermore, evidence shows that this difference is present across several types of temporary workers, including fixed-term workers (Gash & McGinnity, 2006), temporary agency workers (Burgess, Connell, & Rasmussen, 2005), and consultants and interim managers (McKeown, 2005).Moreover, these differences are found even after correcting for objective factors such as seniority, and demographic factors such as gender, age, and educational level (Erdem, Bos, & Hoeben, 2006; Nienhuser & Matiaske, 2006).3 Amended proposal for a directive of the European parliament and the council on working conditions for temporary workers, COM/2002/0701 final, November 2002. Research approachThis research focuses on the mechanisms intrinsic to temporary employment that are related to fair treatment perceptions and the relations of these perceptions to temporary employee attitudes and behaviour.The next sections introduce four studies that focus on these mechanisms and their relevance.The focus is primarily on the psychology of fair treatment perceptions among temporary workers, and on fixed-term contract workers and temporary agency workers in particular.The baseline theory for analysing the psychological mechanisms with respect to fair treatment perceptions of temporary workers is social exchange theory (Blau, 1964;Homans, 1958).This theory includes a process of how employment relations develop and how fair treatment perceptions are central to determining employee work-related attitudes and behaviour.Basically, social exchange theory proposes that receiving certain compensations is related to fair treatment perceptions, and that these perceptions are in turn reciprocated by currencies including employee commitment and performance (Cropanzano, Rupp, Mohler, & Schminke, 2001b).A second approach to analysing the mechanisms behind fair treatment perceptions among temporary workers is provided by recent
Author: de Jong, J.P.
Institution: Tilburg University
Language: English
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6992726492
