Work

A qualitative survey of archivist and technologist perspectives on the use of AI in archives

Year: 2024
Type: conference-paper
Abstract: The opportunities offered by artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) for the archive sector have been addressed in several scholarly articles in recent years. Some of the articles describe projects (e.g. Carter et al., 2022; Han et al., 2022) featuring a collaboration between archivists, generally defined for this paper as persons working in the archival sector, and technologists, defined as persons with a professional technical background. Some other archival projects have been undertaken by computer scientists or digital humanities scholars without the involvement of archivists (e.g. Luthra et al., 2022). Providing a qualitative angle, some articles have looked at digital archivists’ opinions on the implementations of AI techniques in archives (e.g. Cushing & Osti, 2023). Finally, more general articles have been published, both by archivists and technologists on how AI may be implemented in the archival sector (e.g. Colavizza et al., 2022; Hutchinson, 2020; Sabharwal, 2017). This paper presents a qualitative analysis of how the perspectives of archivists and technologists on AI in archives are presented in a selection of recent articles. The selection includes both articles describing case studies, such as project descriptions and interview studies, as well as literature reviews. The articles are categorized according to the type of project described or suggested: articles written from an archival perspective, articles written from a technologist perspective, and articles that describe or propose joint projects run by archivists and technologists in cooperation. Differences can be observed in these research articles regarding 1) how archival expertise is valued, 2) the proposed importance of archival theory for successful AI implementation and 3) the degree of influence ascribed to the archivists in collaborations. The results indicate that viewpoints clearly differ depending on the professional role and background of the contributors to the articles. Articles written from a technologist perspective are more likely to criticize archivist work, and in some cases even blame them for obstructing access and “perpetuating silences” in archives (Luthra et al., 2022). Randby & Marciano (2020) describe the goals of AIC (Advanced Information Collaboratory), a project in which Randby is involved, as aiming towards information professionals learning “to think computationally and rapidly adapt new technologies”; the article goes through a computational workflow without further mentioning archivists on a larger scale. Articles written by archivists, on the other hand, emphasize the importance of incorporating archival principles and taking advantage of archivists’ knowledge in the AI implementation process (Hutchinson, 2020). Cushing & Osti (2023) highlight the expertise of archivists and stress how their professional background is a requisite to control AI decision-making. An important distinction is also that articles published in archivist journals such as Murphy et al.’s (2015) highlight the perspective of archivists by portraying them as subjects (“archivists”) which is contrasted with a passive portrayal of the technological aspects (“technology” instead of “technologists” or “machine learning experts”). Other articles point out the challenges of using AI in archives; for example, Jaillant & Caputo (2022) mention “ethical challenges” and problems with bias in AI. Cushing & Osti (2023) describe how participants in their study (archival experts) are confident about the possibilities of AI, but also skeptical about practical integration into their work. Lee (2018) argues that certain AI tools are not supportive of the “holistic view” that archivists have of their work. Those articles that present a mutual collaboration between archivists and technologists highlight the importance of combining the expertise of both fields for successful AI implementation (e.g. Murphy et al., 2015; Carter et al., 2022; Han et al., 2022). Poole & Garwood (2018), an information scientist and computer and informatics researcher respectively, call for the involvement of archivists and librarians in Digital Humanities projects. Tsabedze (2023) offers an important perspective on archival professionals in Eswatini, highlighting the need for digital education; Tsabedze argues that the interview participants in Eswatini are afraid to lose their jobs without proper training. Nevertheless, Marciano et al. (2018) are positive about the disciplines achieving more together than each would have on their own. As a contrasting addition, Jo & Gebru (2020) argue not for implementing AI technologies in archives but for implementing archival expertise in AI development. They propose that archival document collection practices can inform data collection in sociocultural ML, because archivists possess the language and procedures to address issues of consent, transparency, inclusivity etc. Finally, Marciano et al. (2018) believe that archival expertise of the future will involve knowledge of digital systems. Sabharwal (2017) suggests that in the future, the distinction between archivists and technologists will not be as clear anymore. Jaillant & Caputo (2022) also highly encourage collaboration between archivists and technologists in order to address future challenges. Cushing & Osti (2023) suggest that AI technology in archives can even change how archivists describe “digital archival expertise”. In conclusion, our findings suggest that there is a great diversity of opinions; as Poole & Garwood (2018) suggest, more research is necessary on how the collaboration between professions, as well as implementation of AI in archives, can be improved.
Authors: von Bychelberg, Larissa, Widegren, Johannes
Language: English
Subfield: Conservation
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6996091428
FWCI: 2.764
Cites: 22
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10