The role of the prefrontal cortex in the expression of impulsive- and premeditated- aggression \n
Year: 2011
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: The notion that there is a relationship between frontal lobe damage and \naggressive behaviour has been recognised in the clinical literature for over 50 years. \nHowever, although there is evidence for an association between general brain \ndysfunction and aggression, there is little evidence pertaining to subclinical \nimpairment and the propensity for aggressive behaviour. Further to this, given the \nfunctionally heterogeneity of the prefrontal cortex, it is vital to delineate the specific \nroles of the dorsolateral, orbitofrontal and medial aspects of the prefrontal cortex in \nthe expression of aggression. \nTwo forms of aggression are distinguished: reactive, impulsive-aggression \nand goal-directed premeditated aggression. While impulsive-aggression is typically \ndescribed as an emotionally-charged aggressive response characterised by a lack of \ncontrol, premeditated aggression is considered to be a planned and controlled \naggressive display that is instrumental in nature. The qualitative differences between \nthese subtypes of aggression suggest distinct neuropsychological differences \nmediating the likelihood of their display. \nThe aim of this thesis was to clarify the role of the prefrontal cortex in \nsubclinical impulsive-aggression and premeditated aggression. More specifically, \npossible executive functioning deficits mediated by the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, \nand emotion recognition, impulsivity, and response reversal capabilities mediated by \nthe orbitofrontal cortex were explored. Participants included university \nundergraduate students identified as having high levels of trait aggression, classified \nas either predominantly impulsive, or predominantly premeditated in nature. \nExperiment 1 (n=85) explored possible executive deficits using a battery of neuropsychological measures pertaining to dorsolateral functioning. It was found that \nimpulsive-aggressive individuals performed significantly poorer on measures of \ncognitive flexibility, planning, problem-solving, and flexibility of verbal thought \nprocesses. \nExperiment 2 (n=87) sought to identify possible deficits in interpretations of \nfacial expressions of emotion and hostile attribution biases. Contrary to expectations, \nthe results indicated that while impulsive- and premeditated-aggressive individuals \ndo not incorrectly interpret emotional expressions, premeditated-aggressive \nindividuals attributed greater levels of aggression to neutral faces. \nExperiment 3 (n=87) investigated functions of the orbitofrontal cortex, \nnamely impulsivity, response reversal, and decision-making capabilities. No \ndifferences between impulsive-aggressive and premeditated-aggressive individuals \nwere found on any of these measures suggesting negligible involvement of the \norbitofrontal cortex in subclinical aggression. \nOverall, the results from this thesis suggest distinct neuropsychological \nprocesses in individuals who display predominantly impulsive-aggressive behaviour \ncompared to those who display predominantly premeditated-aggression. While \nimpulsive-aggression may result from executive dysfunction pertaining to the \ndorsolateral region of the prefrontal cortex, the display of premeditated aggression is \nrelated to functioning of the orbitofrontal cortex mediating the interpretation of \naggression in others. Such findings have important implications not only in the \nunderstanding of the causal features of such behaviour, but also in the development \nand implementation of successful treatment strategies.
Source: UTAS Research Repository
Author: Haberle, SK
Institution: University of Tasmania
Language: English
Subfield: Cognitive Neuroscience
Field: Neuroscience
Domain: Life Sciences
Keywords: prefrontal cortex, impulsive aggression, premeditated aggression, trait aggression, dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, orbitofrontal cortex, executive dysfunction, cognitive flexibility, facial emotion recognition, hostile attribution bias, impulsivity, response reversal, decision-making, frontal lobe damage, planning and problem solving
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6996283059
