Work

The Semiotic Nature of Power in Social-Ecological Systems

Year: 2017
Type: dissertation
Abstract: : Anderies (2015); Anderies et al. (2016), informed by Ostrom (2005), aim to employ robust\n\nfeedback control models of social-ecological systems (SESs), to inform policy and the\n\ndesign of institutions guiding resilient resource use. Cote and Nightingale (2012) note that\n\nthe main assumptions of resilience research downplay culture and social power. Addressing\n\nthe epistemic gap between positivism and interpretation (Rosenberg 2016), this dissertation\n\nargues that power and culture indeed are of primary interest in SES research.\n\nHuman use of symbols is seen as an evolved semiotic capacity. First, representation is\n\nargued to arise as matter achieves semiotic closure (Pattee 1969; Rocha 2001) at the onset\n\nof natural selection. Guided by models by Kauffman (1993), the evolution of a symbolic\n\ncode in genes is examined, and thereon the origin of representations other than genetic\n\nin evolutionary transitions (Maynard Smith and Szathmáry 1995; Beach 2003). Human\n\nsymbolic interaction is proposed as one that can support its own evolutionary dynamics.\n\nThe model offered for wider dynamics in society are “flywheels,” mutually reinforcing\n\nnetworks of relations. They arise as interactions in a domain of social activity intensify, e.g.\n\ndue to interplay of infrastructures, mediating built, social, and ecological affordances (An-\n\nderies et al. 2016). Flywheels manifest as entities facilitated by the simplified interactions\n\n(e.g. organizations) and as cycles maintaining the infrastructures (e.g. supply chains). They\n\nmanifest internal specialization as well as distributed intention, and so can favor certain\n\ngroups’ interests, and reinforce cultural blind spots to social exclusion (Mills 2007).\n\nThe perspective is applied to research of resilience in SESs, considering flywheels a\n\nsemiotic extension of feedback control. Closer attention to representations of potentially\n\nexcluded groups is justified on epistemic in addition to ethical grounds, as patterns in cul-\n\ntural text and social relations reflect the functioning of wider social processes. Participatory\n\nmethods are suggested to aid in building capacity for institutional learning.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6996360633
Cites: 88
Cited by:
Related to: 10