Year: 2009
Type: article
Abstract: Identifying Research• Students are aware of the qualitative distinction between published research and general internet sites • Students are not generally sophisticated in their understanding of things like peer-review or currency, there is a common view that if something is published it must be reliable • There is a growing diversity in the kinds of content identified as research but journal articles and books still dominate students' perceptions of what research is • Students are very reliant on library catalogues, databases and staff advice • Research content is seen primarily as a source for assignments and students' perception of research is very much led by the context of their assignments • Students are reluctant to approach their tutor directly in the first instance for advice on what research content to access • Very few students identify undergraduate or postgraduate dissertations as research content Accessing Research• The vast majority of students use either a home computer or a university computer to access research• Most students will go to their library catalogue first, then Google• Although Google, Google Books and Google Scholar are heavily used, the library catalogue is still the preferred first choice for most students• A lot of students use Google but are bewildered by the amount of responses and will rarely look beyond the first couple of pages of search terms• An increasing number of students are using the limited preview facility in Google Books to either read books not in their library or to save themselves the trouble of actually going to the library• Although the trend is towards electronic access for students of all age groups, there is still a significant proportion of students who will use library visits in conjunction with or instead of the internet• The internet is used but also distrusted, many students are aware that sites such as Wikipedia are not respected by their tutors• Some students will use a discipline-specific database to access research.These students have had a better experience of accessing research and some use these databases almost exclusively.However, this means they are dependent on the holdings of the database• Students at all universities expressed dissatisfaction with their library holdings and level of service• There is limited evidence of students using social networking and other Web 2.0 technologies to identify and access research Using Research• Most students use research to support their assignments, so use of research is primarily 'assessment led'• Some students demonstrate a sophisticated engagement with research which they use to develop arguments rather than simply support a point• A significant and encouraging minority also use research to gain a wider knowledge of their field• Students tend to be very selective, using research content which is immediately relevant to their needs.For example, they are happy to use the limited preview pages in Google Books without seeing the wider context of the material in the rest of their books• Many quote or paraphrase research content in their assignments• Graduate Teaching Assistants (GTAs) identify themselves with academics rather than students and demonstrate a sophisticated understanding of the research environment
Source: Jisc Repository (Jisc)
Authors: Hampton-Reeves, S, Mashiter, C, Westaway, J, Lumsden, P, Day, H, Hewertson, H
Language: English
Subfield: Library and Information Sciences
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: research content, information seeking, information literacy, library catalogs, Google Scholar, Google Books, library databases, peer review, source reliability, undergraduate and graduate students, library services, social networking, Web 2.0, research skills development, academic writing, graduate teaching assistants
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6996675844
