Year: 2023
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The first main aim of this exploratory research is to investigate how temporal constraints (as operationalized by tempo and harmonic rhythm) are related to creativity in pattern use (as operationalized by the variability of melodic patterns) in bass lines of eminent jazz bassists. As the second main aim, the research investigates whether learning a large storage of melodic patterns is a necessary requirement for creativity in the generation of bass lines. The research material consists of 42 transcribed bass lines by Paul Chambers and Ron Carter, which corresponds to 9,335 bars of notation. In this study, the original bass lines were reduced to sequences of quarter notes. A Kendall’s tau partial correlation analysis was performed to determine the relationship between tempo/harmonic rhythm and the variability of melodic patterns, when controlling for the length of analyzed bass line reductions. The research was not able to find statistically significant correlations between tempo/harmonic rhythm and the variability of melodic patterns. In Paul Chambers’s bass line reductions (n = 30), the results indicated a statistically non-significant and weak negative correlation between tempo and the variability of melodic patterns (mean absolute tau-b = .18) and a statistically non-significant and negligible correlation between harmonic rhythm and the variability of melodic patterns (mean absolute tau-b = .08). In Ron Carter’s bass line reductions (n = 12), the results indicated a statistically non-significant and weak correlation between tempo and the variability of melodic patterns (mean absolute tau-b = .15) and a statistically non-significant and weak correlation between harmonic rhythm and the variability of melodic patterns (mean absolute tau-b = .14). Although the results are inconclusive, they provide preliminary evidence that tempo and harmonic rhythm may have a small or negligible effect on the variability of melodic patterns in bass lines of eminent jazz bassists. Except for the relationship between tempo and the variability of melodic patterns in Paul Chambers’s bass line reductions, the results did not allow to make conclusions on effect directions. In Paul Chambers’s bass line reductions, 15.8% to 16.9% of all recurring melodic pattern classes occurred at least twice in two or more bass line reductions and covered 41.2% to 83.2% of all melodic patterns depending on pattern length. In Ron Carter’s bass line reductions, 11.2% to 19.4% of all recurring melodic pattern classes occurred at least twice in two or more bass line reductions and covered 13.4% to 63.1% of all melodic patterns depending on pattern length. The results indicate that even if recurring melodic pattern classes covered a large proportion of all melodic patterns at least when the length of analyzed melodic patterns was only two notes, a large proportion of recurring melodic pattern classes did not occur at least twice in two or more bass line reductions. This finding suggests that pre-learned melodic patterns may have a surprisingly small role in the generation of jazz bass lines at least for Paul Chambers and Ron Carter.
Author: Nurmi, Mikko
Institution: University of Jyväskylä
Language: English
Subfield: Music
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6997046273
