Work

Attentional modulations of conscious perception: The causal role of the frontal lobe and its white matter connections

Year: 2021
Type: dissertation
Abstract: At any given moment, we receive much more information that our cognitive \nsystem can consciously process. Therefore, a mechanism is necessary to select \nthe information that is relevant for our goals or for survival, and to filter out the \nirrelevant one. Attention is proposed as one of these mechanisms, preparing the \nsystem to allocate processing resources, selecting relevant information –filtering \nout irrelevant distractors–, and allowing for the control of such processing \nresources. These heterogeneous functions of attention have led to the \nconception of attention as a system composed of three networks: alerting, spatial \norienting, and executive control (Petersen & Posner, 2012). Some attentional \nsystems have also demonstrated their influence over conscious perception by \nmodulating perceptual sensitivity and/or by biasing responses. This has led to \npropose a thigh relationship between attention and conscious perception, and to \nthe search of common neural substrates. \nAttentional processes rely, to a great extent, in fronto-parietal networks \n(Fan et al., 2005). Meanwhile, some theories propose that conscious perception \nemerges when information is represented in a large-scale network of frontoparietal \nregions (Dehaene et al., 2006). Although the involvement of parietal \nregions in conscious perception is widely accepted, there is an extensive debate \nabout a causal involvement of the frontal lobe (Boly et al., 2017; Odegaard et al., \n2017). \nIn this theoretical and empirical context, the main goal of the present \ndoctoral thesis was to delineate the role of frontal regions, and long-range white \nmatter tracts connecting them with other regions in the brain (i.e. the dorsal, \nmiddle, and ventral branches of the superior longitudinal fasciculus, SLF I, II, and III), in the relationship between attention and conscious perception. Specifically, \nwe explored the role of the executive control network, which in this context has \nbeen less explored. This network is involved in the voluntary control of processing \nin novel or complex situations. To accomplish this aim, two different studies were \nconducted: \nIn the first study, we searched for common neural substrates of executive \ncontrol and conscious perception, employing a design of functional \nmagnetic resonance imaging (fMRI). Participants had to detect nearthreshold \nGabor stimuli, while resolving a Stroop task in which \nincongruent trials were infrequent. \nIn the second study, we explored the causal involvement of a frontal \nregion – the right SMA – in the interaction between executive control and \nconscious perception by using online transcranial magnetic stimulation \n(TMS). Additionally, a control (vertex stimulation) and an active condition \n(right frontal eye field [FEF] stimulation) were included. Participants \nperformed a similar task that the one employed in the previous study. \nA common aim of both studies was to explore the involvement of the SLF \nI, II, and III in executive control modulations of conscious perception by \nusing diffusion-weighted imaging (DWI) tractography. \nResults of the fMRI study demonstrated an interaction between executive \ncontrol and conscious perception in the functional coupling between some frontoparietal \nregions, which were more strongly coupled for seen as compared to \nunseen reports, but only when trials were Stroop-congruent. Additionally, the \nmicrostructural properties of the left SLF II significantly correlated with the neural \ninteraction between executive control and conscious perception. The follow up TMS experiment demonstrated that two of such reported frontal regions, the right \nSMA and the right FEF, were causally involved in the interaction between \nexecutive control and conscious perception, but only when white matter \nproperties of the right SLF III or a frontal association tract (i.e. the left frontal \naslant tract) were taken into account. Participants with a greater integrity of the \ntracts were sheltered from the TMS modulation. This suggest, at least, partially \nshared frontal neural substrates for executive control and conscious perception. \nIn conclusion, this doctoral thesis provides new data for the understanding \nof how executive control interacts with conscious perception and about the neural \nmechanisms underlying these interactions. They support that the frontal lobe may \nbe a common neural substrate for executive attention and conscious perception. \nThey also emphasize the role of long-range white matter tracts, reinforcing \nmodels based on distributed networks. Finally, results highlight the importance of \nwhite matter in individual variability in cognitive measures and neuromodulation \neffects, in healthy participants.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6998758476
Cites: 272
Cited by:
Related to: 10