The changing medium of instruction policies of state-schools in recently formed states: a comparative analysis
Year: 2023
Type: dissertation
Abstract: In this thesis I analyse changes to the medium of instruction (MOI) policies of \nprimary and secondary schools of new states which gained independence after \nthe end of the Second World War up to 2015. In it I view MOI policies as drivers \nof linguistic state building, with decisions to use additional languages for teaching \nand learning being evaluated in terms of the threat that they may pose to the \nstatus of official languages and established patterns of social opportunity and \nstatus associated with knowledge of them. I develop and use an expanded \nversion of Bourdieu’s theory of the national linguistic market as a conceptual \nframework to capture the interaction of factors both inside and outside of the state \nwhich may influence MOI policy decisions. \nThe existing comparative literature consists mainly of descriptive studies of \nindividual states or geographical regions. My study is distinctive because it \nfocuses on new states and uses a large, longitudinal, sample to provide a global \nperspective on the choices that new states have made about MOI policies in \nprimary and secondary schools and how these policies have changed. My \nmethodological approach is distinct, using qualitative comparative analysis \n(QCA), an approach which is currently underutilized in comparative education \nresearch, particularly in studies with a temporal component. \nI develop a novel MOI typology, identifying four distinctive models: Purist (only \nthe state language(s) are used); Pragmatic (community languages are used in \nprimary schooling); Accommodating (high status community languages are used \nin secondary school); and Opportunistic (new, high status, languages are \nintroduced as MOI). I argue that, whilst Bourdieu’s concept of linguistic markets \nprovides a powerful basis for understanding MOI policy decisions, the interaction \nof national (internal) linguistic markets with the international (external) linguistic \nmarket needs to be considered to fully understand patterns of MOI policy change \nover time.
Author: Victory, Fiona Margaret Holman
Language: English
Subfield: Linguistics and Language
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6999301868
