Work

A configurational approach to work design for different forms of work

Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The dissertation addresses the evolving environment of distributed work, focusing on how to create a work design that is most favorable to employee outcomes for each form of work (i.e., on-site, hybrid work and remote).The core of this research lies in exploring the interplay between job design characteristics and the employee outcomes in different forms of work.It uses the extended Job Demands Resources Model to conceptualize and set up the analysis of how job demands and resources interact in shaping their work environment through behaviors such as job crafting and work motivation.The primary motivation for this research is to address the gap in traditional work design theories, which are increasingly misaligned with the realities of modern, technology-driven work environments.The study aims to modernize these theories to better meet the needs of knowledge workers in different work environments, especially in light of the increase in distributed work and the significant impact of information and communication technology on work design.The main objective of this thesis is to improve the understanding of optimal work design for different types of work, taking into account some individual and contextual characteristics.It aims to identify the most effective combinations of job characteristics that lead to positive outcomes in different types of work.It seeks to identify the most effective configurations of job design characteristics that lead to positive outcomes in different forms of work.In this way, it intends to contribute both to practical aspects of work design in modern organizations and to the theoretical advancement of work design theories to capture the nuances of today's technologically advanced work environments.The study is organized into four chapters, each dealing with different aspects of work design.The first chapter provides a short background of main examined constructs, i.e., job characteristics, (enriched) work design, The Job Demands Resources Model, as overarching theory, and forms of work, along with distributed work.Second part of this chapter provides a comprehensive overview of the development, current status and future directions of distributed work research, highlighting the shift in focus from the individual to the broader organizational and societal level.It reveals the proliferation of concepts and highlights the usual mistakes.The findings, in a summarizing manner, show how that concepts denoting distributed work differ in terms of the use of information communications technology, the location of the work and the geographical distribution.Last but not least, it illuminates the need for new frameworks for understanding and effectively designing distributed work.Building on that, next part of the chapter aims to examine the intersection of distributed work and work design, and past, present and future of this research.It shows that the research connecting distributed work and work design began in the organizational behavior/organizational psychology field and was connected to different individual-level outcomes.Later, the research on the topic has expanded considerably and became crucial to the fields of organization studies, information systems and technology, human resource management, and (strategic) management.This shows that distributed work became increasingly important for both theory and practice.While research during the first examined period focused more or less on the micro (individual in their work context) level, we can derive from the identified theories that the next (second examined) period also focused on the macro level, putting forth the strategic, industrial economics and firm competitiveness perspective.The Resource-based view came to the forefront and examined various resources, including technology and work design, as one of the main factors of firms' performance and competitive advantage.This part of the chapter also develops an integrative framework of distributed work design, which builds up to the Work design questionnaire model, incorporating information communications technologies characteristics and some other individual, organizational and contextual characteristics revealed by co-citation, cooccurrence and topic modeling.The second chapter deals with the complexity of work design configurations.Firstly, it introduces different, previously found, work design configurations, and highlights the importance of comprehensiveness.Next two parts of the chapter make an important contribution to understanding work design in the digital age and offers practical insights into optimizing human potential during technological advances and different forms of work.Enriched work design has been shown to be beneficial for all forms of work for both, task performance and work-life balance.Specifically for task performance, while we confirm the importance of enriched work design, several specific characteristics and their accompanying configurations (including compensatory effects) are highlighted with regard to the task performance achieved.These include high levels of task identity for all three forms of work.Work performed in a traditional on-site setting additionally requires greater task variety.Conversely, remote work requires high information processing and social support.The hybrid model calls for the most complicated work design that combines essential elements of both the on-site and remote work paradigms, namely task variety and information processing, and also for enhanced mechanisms for job feedback.The hybrid form of work is a universal social phenomenon still on the uptake that likely represents the future of work, and since it combines traditional settings with information and communication technologies, we also emphasize the importance of field-bridging future research of information systems and organizational design areas.When examining work-life balance, we took even more holistic view and integrated work design with new information and communication technology characteristics.The analysis of variance showed that workers who work in hybrid work environments generally have the highest work-life balance, followed by remote employees and onsite workers.Further, the analysis suggests that work design is important for work-life balance across all work forms, but it appears to be most salient for on-site work, followed by hybrid and then remote work.In addition, a necessity analysis reveals common work design requirements for all work forms, highlighting the gravity of information processing, skill variety, and social support.Task variety is critical for on-site and remote work, while IT presenteeism emerges as an important factor for hybrid work.The third chapter examines the boundary conditions of individual characteristics and work context.Firstly, we examined whether organizationally imposed formalization and employees' individual adaptive personality traits (proactive personality and resilience) act as boundary conditions that strengthen this positive relationship.The results showed that enriched work design is positively related to work-life balance.Next, we proposed that formalization moderates the positive relationship between enriched work design and worklife balance but could not find support for this hypothesis.We can conclude that formalization alone does not significantly alter the relationship between enriched work design and work-life balance; however, this finding opened avenues for the potential roles of additional moderators.We then examined the joint moderation of formalization and personality traits on the relationship between enriched work design and work-life balance.We found a significant moderation of formalization and proactive personality (but not resilience) on the relationship between enriched work design and work-life balance.Next part of the chapter takes a look at "the dark side" of digitally-mediated knowledge work.We conclude that both digitally-mediated work and flexible work arrangements can be "mixed blessings", that bring both benefits (work engagement) and burdens (burnout) under certain conditions.Last part of the chapter more closely examines the role of self-initiated modification mechanisms, i.e., job crafting and work motivation.It addresses work design challenges of contemporary digitized work by developing and validating an extended account of technology-optimized enriched work design, and exploring how this construct fosters employee work engagement.In doing so, we propose a key mediating role of selfinitiated work modification mechanisms, addressing potential issues with causality between the two that have been underlined by prior research.We further compare these effects among different forms of work (i.e., on-site, hybrid, remote).Findings showed that work motivation is the driving force behind job crafting more so than the other way around, and that the relationship between tech-optimized enriched work design and work engagement is indeed mediated by work motivation and moderated by forms of work.It highlights the importance of incorporating information and communication technology characteristics into work design and considering forms of work as a key boundary condition for its effects.Furthermore, the study offers interesting theoretical contributions and practical implications related to designing jobs, the future of work, and work engagement.The final chapter of the dissertation summarizes the key findings, theoretical contributions and practical implications, building a bridge between human resource management practices, work organization and the future of work.It emphasizes the main aim of the thesis and shows how it has improved understanding in these interrelated areas.The chapter highlights the importance of work design in the context of changing forms of work, particularly in the digital age, and its impact on individual outcomes.This synthesis of research findings and practical insights makes an
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6999391572
Cites: 554
Cited by: 1
Related to: 7