Work

Cultureel diverse klaslokalen , onvoorbereide leraren? Een onderzoek met gemengde methoden naar de lerarenopleiding voor diversiteit in Vlaanderen

Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Summary This doctoral study focuses on the preparation of teachers for diversity, equity, and social justice in today's super-diverse societies. Globalization and international migration have created greater ethnic, cultural, and linguistic diversity within classrooms, particularly in Western European settings. However, the current frameworks of schooling and education, including curriculum design, content, pedagogical practices, and embedded cultural and linguistic norms, are systematically deepening educational inequities for students from diverse ethnic, cultural, and linguistic backgrounds. In an effort to promote equity for all students, teacher education programs worldwide, as well as those in Flanders, are increasingly integrating diversity, equity, and social justice into their curricula. These efforts aim to equip future teachers with the necessary knowledge (expertise) and challenge their existing biases towards culturally and linguistically diverse students, parents, and communities. This mixed-method study investigates how preservice programs in Flanders integrate diversity, equity, and social justice within their curricula and the impact of these curricular efforts in shaping preservice teachers' knowledge and beliefs. The study is guided by two main research questions: (1) What knowledge and beliefs do preservice teachers hold regarding cultural and linguistic diversity and how are these related to their preservice curricula? (2) In what ways are diversity and equity integrated within preservice curricula across Flanders, and which approaches are perceived as the most influential in shaping knowledge and beliefs? These two guiding questions have been translated into several specific research objectives, which are addressed across six different empirical chapters. The first three quantitative investigations examined preservice teachers' knowledge and beliefs about ethnic, cultural, and linguistic diversity in Flanders. These investigations revealed that, in general, preservice teachers have low levels of diversity knowledge and hold certain biases towards students' cultures and languages. However, significant differences were observed at the program level, indicating that a higher focus on theoretical courses and improved knowledge and beliefs are indeed linked. There was no association between internships and an increase in knowledge and beliefs. A longitudinal study, chapter 4, delved deeper and demonstrated a significant growth in knowledge and beliefs even within the first year of the program. This study suggests that a combined approach -which integrates diversity within both the general theoretical curriculum and specific diversity courses- plays a crucial role in fostering this change. Collectively, these four empirical studies highlighted the role of preservice curriculum, especially theoretical courses in shaping preservice teachers' knowledge and beliefs. The final two chapters, therefore, investigated teacher education curricula at two levels: the intended curriculum (curriculum on paper) and the attained curriculum (perceived by students). The analysis of curricular documents and focus group discussions revealed a multifaceted landscape of integrating diversity, equity, and social justice into preservice curricula. Some programs exhibit a clear commitment to these crucial topics, adopt an inclusive approach, and integrate diversity and equity modules from entrance through graduation. This approach fosters knowledge growth and challenges potential biases. Some others, however, adopt a superficial and colorblind approach. These programs may add merely optional courses which often fail to promote diversity knowledge and potentially reinforce pre-existing biases, rather than challenging them. Overall, the findings from this study emphasize the critical need to move beyond superficial approaches towards a more holistic integration of diversity, equity, and social justice in teacher education. These findings contribute significantly to the ongoing debate on preparing teachers for diversity. The whole research process, from data collection and instrument design to theoretical frameworks and analysis opens new directions for future research and practice.
Source: Lirias
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6999614326
Cites: 191
Cited by:
Related to: 10