Efectos de la aplicación de un analgésico de mentol previo al entrenamiento de la fuerza muscular sobre parámetros de dolor y capacidad funcional de mujeres mayores con síndrome de dolor lumbar crónico
Year: 2021
Type: dissertation
Study design: Clinical Trial
Abstract: Chronic low back pain (CLP) affects more than 30% of older adults living in the community and is the most prevalent musculoskeletal condition in this population, which is why it has become one of the most common reasons for consultation among older people who are cared for in primary health care services. It is for this reason that CLP is considered today a “silent epidemic” that directly impacts the functionality and quality of life of the elderly with consequent high health costs that burden health systems. Besides, the origin of this syndrome is multifactorial, which means that the diagnosis is non-specific, and there is little evidence in the literature of sufficient quality to provide clear guidelines as to which approach is optimal. In spite of this, physical exercise based on muscle strength training has positioned itself as a therapy that can have positive effects in the improvement of the functional consequences associated with this syndrome, which can be performed with elastic resistance devices that, due to their characteristics, allow the delivery of a significant stimulus at low cost and great potability. Also, there are topical analgesic alternatives on the market such as menthol gels that have demonstrated a short-term analgesic effect without intervening in the parameters of training, which, in addition to muscle strength training, can be an effective alternative when treating CLD in older people. Purpose. To evaluate the effect on pain parameters and functional capacity after the application of an intervention that combines a muscle strength training program together with the pre-session application of a menthol gel in older women with CLP syndrome. A further objective of the project was the analysis of possible effects on body composition. Methodology.A total of 31 older females met the eligibility criteria and agreed to participate in this research voluntarily. In the 12-week “phase 1”, participants were randomly assigned: (a) control group (CG; n=11); (b) strength training group with pre-applied menthol gel (STM; n=10); and (c) group that performed the same training with pre-applied placebo gel (STP; n=10). After 12 weeks of detraining, “phase 2” began, in which the STM and STP women were randomly reassigned to two new groups that repeated the intervention process of phase 1 but for 32 weeks instead. Both intervening groups applied a topical menthol gel or placebo, as the case may be, in the lumbar area during the 10 minutes before starting the strength to a moderate-high intensity training session with variable resistance devices of the elastic type exercising the large muscle groups of the upper and lower extremities. In both phases of the research, the pain was evaluated with the visual analogue scale (VAS), functional capacity with the Oswestry disability index (ODI), the 6-minute walking test, balance with the tests: Timed Up and Go and unipodal stay, upper and lower limb prehensile and isometric strength and abdominal resistance with the curl-up test. In addition, body composition was tested. The results were analyzed by applying an ANOVA analysis of variance with the Bonferroni test to determine in which group the changes occurred; for all these calculations, a statistically significant difference of p ≤0.05 was accepted. Furthermore, the effect size was calculated with the Cohen test and the changes produced after the intervention program in both phases were contrasted, considering the minimal significant clinical differences (MCID) published in the literature. Results. STM and STP significantly improved (p≤0.05) all the variables without difference between them at the end of each phase of the investigation. However, STM showed more significant improvements with a moderate to high effect in most of the variables of functional capacity. Large reductions in pain perception and functional increases occurred mainly in phase 1, with moderate improvements also being obtained throughout phase 2. The CG in phase 1 remained with no significant changes and there was a tendency for the data to worsen the indicators. When the effects were contrasted with the MCID published in the literature, it was evidenced that these differences were generated from the first 12 weeks for pain and disability index. Conclusion.The use of a menthol gel before the sessions of a moderate-high intensity strength training program acted reducing pain and enhancing the functional improvements achieved as a result of such training, so its correctly individualized use is recommended as a complement to an intervention program to train muscle strength in older women with nonspecific CLP. The longer the intervention program is, even more significant all these improvements will be.
Author: Fritz, Nicole B.
Institution: Universitat de València
Language: English
Field: Health Professions
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7000133209
