Examining the Cycle: How Perceived and Actual Bicycling Risk Influence Cylcing Frequency, Roadway Design Preferences, and Support for Cycling Among Bay Area Residents
Year: 2013
Type: preprint
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: This dissertation investigates the connection between perceived and actual bicycling risk, and how they both affect and are affected by one's attitudes, knowledge, behavior, and experiences.Understanding bicycling risk has gained importance as efforts by the U.S. Department of Transportation, the Environmental Protection Agency, the Centers for Disease Control & Prevention, and others have urged communities to increase cycling for its health, environmental, and social equity benefits.Research has identified numerous barriers to increased bicycling in the U.S., including topography, weather, and trip distance, but the barrier that appears most consistently between studies is the perceived hazard associated with cycling near motorists.Yet, little research has fully explored the concept of risk to understand its component parts, including how 1) various driver actions affect perceived and actual cycling risk, 2) reported crash statistics reflect perceived and actual risk, 3) roadway design preferences are affected by perceived risk, and 4) attitudes toward cycling and cycling risk-especially among drivers-influence support for bicycling in one's community.A deeper understanding of perceived and actual risk is critical for knowing how to address it, and, ultimately, to encourage more people to bicycle.To begin to answer these questions and demystify bicycling risk, this dissertation employs three main methods: focus groups, an online survey (n=463), and an analysis of reported crash data from the San Francisco Bay Area, one of the regions at the forefront of cycling efforts in the U.S.My findings confirm that perceived and actual cycling risk influence the decision to bicycle, but indicate that the causal pathways are more nuanced than previously understood.First, my data suggest that cyclists experience two types of roadway risk: pervasive risk in the form of near misses that occur frequently, and acute risk that occurs when a cyclist is struck-a less frequent, but more injurious incident.Both types-but particularly near missessignificantly affect perceived risk for cyclists and their family and friends, yet we lack systematic data on near misses and are therefore almost completely ignorant about the extent and effect of their occurrence.Routinely-collected reported crash data provide only limited insight into the type and extent of risk cyclists experience.Second, roadway design preferences are significantly related to perceived risk, and particularly important for attracting new cyclists.Surprisingly, drivers and cyclists both prefer roadway designs with separated space for bicyclists, particularly if barrier-separated, regardless of cycling frequency.Shared space designs are less popular among drivers and much less I am grateful for the support of the University of California Transportation Center, the UC Berkeley Dean's Normative Time Fellowship, and the Eisenhower Transportation Program while writing this dissertation.In addition, I owe thanks to a number of incredibly talented and generous individuals who have helped me with vision, content, and editing.I want to thank my advisor, Elizabeth Deakin, for hours of conversation and constructive feedback.I also want to thank my Masters degree advisor and committee member, Elizabeth Macdonald, for her encouragement and gentle reminders to view this research from various angles and remember my urban design training.I am grateful to Robert Cervero for his guidance wandering through the land of structural equation models and statistics in general.Many thanks also go to Bill Satariano, my outside field advisor, for his patient
Author: Sanders, Rebecca L
Language: English
Subfield: Transportation
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7000281545
