Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Tackling climate change requires setting a price on CO2 emissions. In the transportation sector, the most straightforward way to achieve this is to impose a tax on fuel. However, fuel taxes often face strong public opposition due to their perceived unfairness. To evaluate these concerns, the first two essays of this dissertation study how the economic burdens created by fuel taxation are distributed in society. In the first essay, my co-authors and I analyze the distributional impacts of fuel taxation by estimating how strongly fuel taxes are passed through to fuel prices. Using gas station-level data on fuel prices, we study the price effects of a large diesel tax increase implemented in Finland in 2012 and document two main findings. First, on average only 80 percent of the tax increase was passed through to diesel prices, meaning that a part of the tax burden was borne by fuel suppliers. Second, pass-through rates exhibited systematic regional variation such that diesel prices saw the largest increases in the most rural and lowest-income areas. In the second essay, my co-author and I study the distribution of fuel tax burdens in more detail at the household level. We measure tax burdens as the share of disposable income spent on fuel taxes and estimate these burdens for nearly all Finnish households in 2016. The analysis is made possible by car-level data on mileage and fuel economy, as well as individual-level data on income and other socioeconomic characteristics. We find that fuel taxes are not regressive among the population of all households. Rather, upper middle-income households bear the highest average burdens. This finding is explained by car ownership being uncommon at low incomes. In contrast, if we only consider car-owning households, fuel taxes do appear regressive. However, differences across income deciles explain only 1.5 percent of the total variation in tax burdens. The substantial horizontal variation is difficult to explain with observable household characteristics, but we find that households that live in more rural areas, have children, or are employed tend to face higher burdens. Finally, we show that average tax burdens across income deciles could easily be equalized by redistributing the tax revenue, but the large within-decile differences are almost impossible to eliminate with transfers. If fuel taxes cannot be increased due to public opposition, alternative climate policies might be needed. In the third essay, I study the effects of public transit pricing on car use and emissions. I analyze a 2019 pricing reform in the Helsinki region in Finland that lowered public transit fares by 45 percent for individuals living in a specific travel zone. Using individual-level data on mileage, car ownership and home locations, I compare individuals who received the price cut to those who lived just outside the travel zone and experienced almost no change in prices. I find a clear reduction in mileage in response to the price cut, with cross-price elasticity estimates ranging between 0.06 and 0.27. However, I find no response in car ownership. Back-of-the-envelope calculations suggest that the cost of reducing emissions with this reform landed in the range of €1000–€3000 per tonne of CO2, making the price cut an expensive climate policy tool.
Source: Aaltodoc (Aalto University)
Author: Palanne, Kimmo
Language: English
Field: Energy
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7000374261
