Work

Gender and abusive victimization : gender and childhood family abuse as predictors of adulthood partner abuse

Year: 1987
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This second category or definition of woman abuse as physical.assault is, currenlly, the nost frequently referenced category of definitíon in the published literature, and appears to be ctosely tied to tegal definitions of physical assault.Àssumptions that so-caIIed "more severe" acts of assault and/or more frequent attacks cause more damage or harm to the victim are ímplied by rnost of these researchers, yet a fe!¡ recognize and argue against these assumptions (Dobash & Dobash, 1979; Pagelow, 1981; RusseIl, 1982), PageloÌr and RusselL are both particularly critical of the CTS and its limitations in the measurement of woman abuse.Pagelow (1981) argues that the intensiLy of the bIows, the severity of injuries (if any) sustained, and the meanings of the acts as understood by both the offender and the victim are inportant variables omitted by Straus et al. (1980).Pagelow aLso notes lhat the SLraus et aI.study focused prirnarily on behavior during the previous yearf yet prior acts may have had great impac! on thè relationships.RusseIl (1982) is critical that Straus et al. did not report on lhe percentage of wives assaulted r¡ithin !he broader "overall vioLence index" but subsumed it under violence between couples.Russell argues that the conclusions drawn from lhe CTS data by Straus et al. are erroneous because their data faiL to distinguish betlJeen defensive and offensive vioJ.ence,bet!reen men's and women's typically differentiaL strength and fighting skills, and betlleen the degree of hurt and injury typically resulting from violence done by men and women.These distinctions are importan!and impact on both reported incidence and prevalence statistics of woman abuse, as well as on the explanations and suggesled remedies for violence against r,romen , although these many definÍtions of r,roman battering as physical assault may, at first glance, appear c ompa rable.'1 1 (g) phvsical, psycholoqical and/or sexual violence The third category or type of definition of woman abuse is most frequently used by feminist researchers and is currently endorsed by several cornmunity and governnent organizaLions in Manitoba.Generally, definitíons in this ca!egory include physical assault, and extend to include emotional, psychological and verbal abuse, and may aLso include sexual assault, walker (1979) defines a battered Homan as a wornan who is "repeatedly subjecled to any forcefuJ.physicaì or psychological behavior by a man in order to coerce her to do something he wants her to do without any concern for her rights" (p.xv).Psychological.abuse is described as psychological humiliation, verbal harassnent, and/or lhe threat of physical violence.Walker's definition includes that the couple must go through a vioLent cycIe, which she describes, at least two tines to distinguish lhe behavior as "batlering".MacLeod (1980), a Canadian researcher, defines !ronan battering as "violence, physical and/or psychological, expressed by a husband or a male or lesbian Live-in lover to!¡ards his wife or his/her live-in lover, to which the 'wife' does not consent, and which is directly or indirectly condoned by the traditions, laws, and atliludes prevalent in the society in which it occurs" (p. 7).PsychologicaJ.vioLence is described as denigration, taunts, purposeful inconsistencies, or threats.Pagelor.l (1981) defines battered rlomen as "adult r¡omen who were intentionalJ.yphysicalJ.yabused in rlays that caused pain or injury, or who riere forced into involuntary action or restrained from voluntary aclion by rvife. in a quarter of lhe couples (4% o!. totat) only the husbands were violent, and the other quarter (4% of totaL) reported that onJ.y the wíves were víoIent.Several major criticisms of these dala have been made.Firstly, that no distinction was made be!Ìreen offensive and defensive behavior, Secondly, that the inlensity of physicaL assault and hurt and injury rlas not neasured.Thirdly, thãt the primary focus of study was a 12 month period, wilh no distinction between victin or assailant behavior nade prior to that 12 month period (Breines & cordon, 1983; Dobash & Dobash, 1979; pagelow, 1981; Russell, 1982i Stacey & Shupe, 1983).These criLicisms may account for the incidence rates reported by Straus et al. (1980) being discrepant from those reported by Frieze (1983) and Russell (1982).Femi n i st theorv Feminism, a perspective advocating economic, lega1, social and political equality for lromen and men, indicates that gender discrimination is overtty and covertly practiced agains!women in our patriarchal society (¡allou t Gabalac, 1985; Dworkin, 1978; Martin, '1 983; Rush, 1980).For at least 300 years (Spender, 1982), feminists have been identifying sexism, sex-role stereotypíng, and power inequalities in the socialization of girls and women.This functionaLly Limits the social and economic options of women primarily to the unpaid roles of molher and wife, who serve others before self.Câreers for women are discouraged or funneled primarily into the low-paid "pink-collar ghettos" of support, secretarial, and maintenance personnel.The cLassical psychology of men and "mankind", which commonly omits or devalues wonen, has been chal.lengedand continues to be re-writLen
Author: Rycroft, Patricia J.
Language: English
Subfield: Health
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7000544814
Cites: 34
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10