The impact of debate discussion via zoom platform on enhancing secondary students’ critical thinking and English argumentative writing skills
Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Study design: Clinical Trial
Abstract: Employing online instruction strategies, and turning virtual learning into a \nplatform that effectively provides cooperative learning and social interaction to learn \nEnglish and acquire thinking, social, and communication skills is worth investigating. \nThis study aimed at examining the impact of debate via Zoom (DVZ) in secondary \nstudents' writing argument and critical thinking skills, also, social and communication \nskills (verbal and nonverbal). \nThe population of this study is composed of 330 students in Arab sector schools \nin Israel. To achieve the study objectives, a purposive sample consisting of 60 male and \nfemale students was taken. They were equally divided into two groups: the tenth and \neleventh-grade students of both schools (n =30) attended the experimental group, and \nthe other two classes (n =30) served as a control group. \nThe research method of this study followed the explanatory sequential mixed \nmethod, where quantitative and qualitative research methods were adopted and the \nresults of both methods were displayed and compared. The quantitative research was \nrepresented by an experimental approach, a quasi-experiment. Pre- and post-tests were \nconducted, which were: a writing test that examined students' argument writing skills, \nWatson and Glaser appraisal, tested students' critical thinking abilities, and a \nquestionnaire was distributed to investigate students' attitudes toward learning DVZ. \nThe quantitative research was represented by designing four questions and gathering \nstudents' responses. Also, classroom observation was done with a concentration on \nrubrics that classified communication skills, writing skills, and critical thinking skills. \nThe quantitative research data was gathered and analyzed by using Statistical Package \nfor the Social Sciences (SPSS). While the qualitative research data collection and \nanalysis through thematic analysis for the students' responses were analyzed by \nMAXQDA 2022. The classroom observation was done by thematic analysis. \nThe finding of this research study revealed that DVZ is an effective teaching \nmethod in enhancing students' critical thinking and argumentation writing skills, as \nstudents' scores showed a high increase in inference, recognition of assumptions, and \nan equal increase in interpretation, and evaluating the argument respectively. students' \nargumentative writing skills, students' scores for the post-test have sharply increased due to teaching methods compared to the pre-test. There was a significant improvement \nin writing introductions, conclusions, tone, word choice, convention, evidence and \nelaboration, organization, and transition, while rebuttal scores showed an increase \nalbeit not significant. \nFindings revealed that there are statistically significant differences at (α≤ 0.05) \nin students' perspectives toward the impact of DVZ on students’ critical thinking skills, \nargumentative writing, and social skills, and 74% of the responses agreed that DVZ \nenhances students to be more courageous to answer questions, and 68 agreed that DVZ \nprovides students with the chance to practice the language. Comparing all the findings \nshowed that nonverbal communication skills scores were not significant, gender, type \nof electronic device, grade, and specialization don't show significant differences \nbetween the two groups. \nQuantitative research findings indicated that the majority of students have \npositive opinions about the impact of DVZ in improving argumentative writing skills \nsuch as writing introductions, drawing conclusions, and bringing more shreds of \nevidence for the reasons. Moreover, DVZ developed thinking and encouraged verbal \nand nonverbal communication among students. Few students argued that Zoom is an \ninefficient digital medium of instruction due to reasons like privacy, cyberbullying, and \nridiculing and mocking by other classmates. \nThe main suggestions provided by participants were access to a good internet \nconnection; a rule obligating students to open the camera in meetings; also, having short \nsessions, and learning in small groups. \nResults of classroom observation acknowledged DVZ's impact on students. The \nchange was clearly seen in the domain of respect for others, and the use of facts and \nstatistics to support the claim of the argument, advanced students’ abilities to organize \ntheir arguments as well as develop critical thinking skills. Finally, there was some \ncorrespondence between both qualitative and quantitative findings. The researcher \nrecommended conducting cross-cultural studies to explore how students from different \ncultural backgrounds and cultures engage in DVZ and whether the effectiveness of the \napproach varies across cultures. Moreover, performing a comparative analysis of the \noutcomes of DVZ with debates using other online platforms or even traditional faceto- \nface debates.
Author: Aarar, Manal Ameen Mosa
Institution: Universidad de Granada
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: online debate, critical thinking, argumentative writing, English as a foreign language, high school students, social and communication skills, verbal and nonverbal communication, cooperative learning, online instruction, student attitudes toward online learning, Watson-Glaser Critical Thinking Appraisal
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7001136669
