Year: 2023
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Unified Silla strengthened management and control of the state in various sectors of society by establishing a highly centralized system. As part of this, it has been suggested that the production and distribution of pottery were managed or controlled centrally by Unified Silla, and the spread and standardization hypothesis of Unified Silla pottery has been used to support this view archaeologically. \n However, this explanation is excessively state-centric, overlooking the diverse ways in which various economic agents may have produced and distributed pottery. As it is expected that highly complex societies will be characterized by varied and complicated forms of economic organization, it is necessary to consider actors other than the state in order to understand the political economy of Unified Silla. Therefore, this study focuses on the private sector as a major economic agent in comparing and reviewing the production and distribution of pottery by the state and within the private sector in order to infer the political and economic implications of pottery production and distribution in Unified Silla. \n In this study, the excavation patterns of Unified Silla pottery were identified in Seoul and Gyeonggi province, the level of morphological variation was compared with that of Gyeongju, and the distribution range of pottery was investigated through geochemical analysis (INAA and pXRF). The results of these analyses confirm that stamped-design pottery, which is considered a representative type of Unified Silla pottery, was excavated almost exclusively at fortress sites in Seoul and Gyeonggi province and only one production site has been discovered thus far. This pattern is thought to reflect the special function and characteristics of stamped-design pottery in Unified Silla pottery. Considering its highly decorative form and limited production-consumption patterns, stamped-design pottery likely held a higher social value than Mumun pottery, which was widely used in everyday life. More specifically, it is proposed that stamped-design pottery may have been used as utilitarian, serving, and ritual vessels by local officials in fortresses. \n As a result of reviewing the chronology of Unified Silla pottery in Gyeongju and comparing it with pottery excavated from fortresses in Seoul and Gyeonggi province, Unified Silla pottery in Seoul and Gyeonggi shows a relatively similar shape to those in Gyeongju. On the other hand, in the case of settlements, the level of morphological variation is much more diverse than in the Gyeongju area, and in particular, in the case of bowls or jars, morphological variation is observed among each site. \n The results of geochemical analysis of Unified Silla pottery in Seoul and Gyeonggi province support the results of the morphological analysis. Pottery from Sadang-dong, Seoul and pottery from Hoamsan Fortress and Achasan Fortress were not distinguishable geochemically, suggesting that pottery produced at Sadang-dong was widely distributed. On the other hand, analysis of pottery from settlement sites reveals that pottery clearly differentiated at the site level. \n Taken together, it is suggested that a government production-distribution system, centered on fortresses, and a private production-distribution system, centered on settlements, coexisted in Seoul and Gyeonggi province during the Unified Silla Period. This dual distribution network was likely the result of decision-making by the state and private sector producers/consumers that took into consideration their respective needs, objectives, and economic levels. In the case of the state, it is suggested that a small number of base facilities produced pottery for official use and distributed it to fortresses in order to stably supply high-quality pottery needed for fortresses and achieve economies of scale. Since there was a water transportation system in place for tax collection and transportation, it is possible that the cost of long-distance transportation was not high. \nOn the other hand, in the private sector, production-distribution patterns of settlement units may have appeared because transportation costs acted as the biggest constraint in the procurement of daily-use pottery. Consumers at the individual household level would have likely preferred to avoid high transport costs associated with procuring pottery from distant locations, unless the pottery held a special function or was a luxury item. \n Excessively state-centric interpretations are highly likely to result in incomplete understandings of the complexly differentiated Unified Silla society. The more complicated society was, the more diverse avenues of production and distribution coexisted, and in the case of Unified Silla, there were major differences in production and distribution modes between the state and the private sector. As these systems of production and distribution likely emerged as a result of both the function of pottery and its basic physical properties, it is thought that different types of goods would have been produced and distributed in different ways, and thus, will likely leave other varied traces on the material culture.
Author: 김현우
Institution: Seoul National University
Language: Korean
Subfield: Archeology (arts and humanities)
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7004566686
