A Palearctic Contribution to Bat Fungal Disease Puzzle - Environmental Factors, Host Communities, Overwintering Habitats and Climate Change Contribute to the Manifestation of White-nose Disease
Year: 2023
Type: dissertation
Abstract: White-nose disease (WND) is a fungal disease of hibernating bats, caused by the psychrophilic fungus Pseudogymnoascus destructans. The disease was first discovered in 2006, when hibernating bats in upstate New York were found with white fungal growth around their ears, wings and muzzles. Since then, the disease has spread across North America, killing millions of bats, and resulting in population collapses in many affected areas, earning its reputation as one of the most detrimental wildlife diseases of modern times. The causative agent, P. destructans, is endemic to the Palearctic and was introduced to North America from Europe. The disease does not cause significant mortality in Palearctic bats, likely due to the long coevolution between the pathogen and the hosts, but the mechanisms behind the low mortality have remained largely unknown. It is also unclear, why the disease does not manifest (visible fungal growth, diagnostic cupping erosions on infected skin) throughout the distribution range of the pathogen. The purpose of this thesis is to provide a holistic view of the factors contributing to WND in the Palearctic by taking in to account all aspects of the disease triangle: the pathogen, the host, and the environment. In chapter I, I used hibernation site census data and open-source climate data from across Europe to determine how species composition within hibernacula and local climatic conditions affect the manifestation of the disease. I found three species/species groups that had a positive association with the occurrence of WND (Myotis emarginatus, M. myotis/blythii and M. mystacinus/brandtii), and two species that had a negative association with the disease (Rhinolophus ferrumequinum, R. hipposideros). In addition, I discovered a link between climatic conditions (mean annual surface temperature, annual precipitation) and the probability of disease manifestation, which enabled me to elucidate the potential global distribution of the disease and further create predictions on how climate change may shift these areas. In chapter II, I have illuminated the mechanisms facilitating the survival of the two main hosts, M. myotis in Europe and M. lucifugus in North America. The results show that M. myotis, a species that has coexisted with the pathogen for millennia, does not mount local immune reactions during infection, suggesting that the species is tolerant against WND. In contrast, M. lucifugus from a remnant population with short exposure history with the pathogen, showed signs of immunological resistance mechanisms. In chapters III and IV, I used passive acoustic monitoring to investigate the use of novel hibernation sites in an area that lacks caves and reveal how weather conditions affect the activity of bats during the winter. The results show that rock outcrops with cracks and crevices are likely important hibernacula in areas without available caves, suggesting that these habitats may offer some protection against WND if climate change shifts the distribution range of the disease towards North. In addition, acoustic monitoring revealed new information on the expansion of the overwintering range of Pipistrellus nathusii, providing further evidence of the species’ response to climate change. In addition, the finding highlights the potential future shifts in the distribution ranges of other hibernating bat species, including those that are affected by WND. The findings of this thesis emphasize the importance of host species composition and environmental conditions for the manifestation of the disease and raise concern for multiple areas that may be climatically suitable for the disease and are therefore at risk if the pathogen is introduced. In addition, the results highlight the massive potential that climate change may have for the distribution range of WND, and provide more evidence on the climate change related expansion of one hibernating bat species. The study presents two cost-efficient monitoring methods for WND. Visual assessment of WND (chapter I) is an effective way of monitoring the disease in areas where bats use traditional, accessible hibernacula, and passive acoustic monitoring (chapters III and IV) can be used to detect sickness behaviour in areas with novel hibernation sites such as rock crevices. The results of this thesis also draw attention for the need to gain more information on the mechanisms of tolerance and resistance in Nearctic and Palearctic bats. If the ability to tolerate infection allows bats to cope with WND without apparent costs, further studies could help predict the future of Nearctic and potentially other areas as well, if containing the pathogen in its current ranges fail.
Source: UTUPub (University of Turku)
Author: Blomberg, Anna
Language: English
Domain: Life Sciences
Keywords: Pseudogymnoascus destructans, hibernating bats, hibernacula, Myotis myotis, Myotis lucifugus, greater horseshoe bat, Rhinolophus hipposideros, Myotis emarginatus, Myotis mystacinus, Myotis brandtii, disease tolerance, local immune response, pathogen survival, fungal virulence, host-pathogen coevolution, climate change
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7005036207
