Work

Advancements in Supply Chain Resilience Research: Present Challenges, Promising Solutions, and Technological Innovation

Year: 2023
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Recent supply chain (SC) disruptions, first and foremost the devastating COVID-19 pandemic, revealed the vulnerability and fragility of today’s SCs. Mismatches between supply and demand dominated the agenda of multinational companies across industries and geographies, leading to an increasing importance of the supply chain management (SCM) domain. Research and practice intensified their efforts to improve supply chain resilience (SCRES) and overcome adverse SC performance consequences. This dissertation, including six essays applying three different methodologies, provides valuable contributions to this highly-topical subject. Two systematic literature reviews analyze current SCRES opportunities emerging from industry 4.0 (I4.0) and blockchain. A multiple and a single case study design explore SC challenges and solutions in two key sectors, the healthcare and the automotive industry, during the COVID-19 pandemic. Finally, two Delphi studies complement future prospects by examining the effect of I4.0 and circular economy (CE) practices on SCRES in the year 2030. The essays’ multiple perspectives on SCRES contribute to theory building and provide practitioners with essential guidance in steering SCRES efforts and choosing appropriate measures in these challenging times. The first essay, “Improving Supply Chain Resilience through Industry 4.0: A Systematic Literature Review under the Impressions of the COVID-19 Pandemic,” targets a major research gap in supply chain risk management (SCRM) literature by conceptualizing the relationship between I4.0 and SCRES. Based on a systematically derived sample of 62 high-quality journal articles, a comprehensive framework depicting the relationship between different I4.0 technologies, SCRES antecedents, and SCRES phases is introduced. It reveals, among others, that big data analytics is particularly suitable for improving SCRES, while additive manufacturing and cyber-physical systems still lack proof of effectiveness. Moreover, visibility and velocity are the resilience antecedents that benefit most from I4.0 implementation. The effect on other antecedents such as SCRM culture and SC (re-)engineering is still not clearly understood. The framework also reveals that I4.0 holistically supports pre-disruption resilience measures, enabling more effective proactive risk management. The framework is applied to a use case, the COVID-19-affected automotive industry, to verify the results' coherence and support practical implementation. The second research paper, “Is the Blockchain the Holy Grail for achieving Supply Chain Resilience? Insights from a Literature Review,” focuses on another technological innovation with promising SCRES potential, the blockchain. Although many scholars claimed a positive effect of the distributed ledger technology on SCRES, a conceptualization for this crucial relationship was still missing in SCRM literature. The present contribution closes this research gap by systematically analyzing a sample of 62 peer-reviewed journal articles and conference papers at the intersection of blockchain and SCRES. More specifically, the link between specific blockchain characteristics, SCRES antecedents, and SC risk types is explored. The results reveal that visibility and validation are the most relevant blockchain characteristics for improving SCRES. The SCRES antecedents agility, collaboration, and SC (re-)engineering can benefit from blockchain implementation, whereas the effect on SCRM culture is widely unexplored. While there is consensus on blockchain’s usability for mitigating security, operational, and supply risks, the effect on demand risks requires further attention. To facilitate the practical implementation of this paper’s results, the findings served as a foundation for discussing SCRES opportunities emerging from well-known blockchain applications such as smart contracts and tracking solutions. SC managers can use these insights to understand and implement the SCRES opportunities emerging from blockchain technology. Moreover, six promising research avenues at the intersection of blockchain and SCRES are presented to steer future interdisciplinary research efforts. The third essay, “Improving Resilience of the Healthcare Supply Chain in a Pandemic: Evidence from Europe during the COVID-19 Crisis,” shifts the perspective from past-based learning to empirically analyzing present SCRES challenges resulting from the COVID-19 pandemic. Considering the severe scarcity of critical medical supplies over several months, the healthcare sector and the procurement function are of particular interest. The present essay is based on the resource dependence theory (RDT) and offers empirical evidence from a multi-tier case study spanning nine European medical supplies manufacturers and hospital groups. Semi-structured interviews with 39 senior SCM experts and abundant secondary data served as a unique foundation for deriving seven novel propositions to reduce evolving procurement dependencies and strengthen SCRES during a pandemic. All propositions are related to bridging (reliance on existing procurement sources) or buffering (activation of new procurement sources) RDT measures. The results advance theory by revealing that bridging approaches within the healthcare supply base, such as supplier procurement support, are more effective for securing medical supplies during a pandemic than buffering measures. However, complementing bridging with buffering, even across industry boundaries, can lead to superior risk mitigation since focusing on the present supplier base may not suffice. Healthcare professionals can build on these results to prepare a powerful mix of bridging and buffering countermeasures for potential future pandemics. Moreover, policy-making can benefit from this study since major weaknesses in private-public pandemic response coordination were discovered. The fourth research paper, “How did Supply Chain Networks handle the COVID-19 Pandemic? Empirical Evidence from an automotive Case Study,” also applies a case study design to explore SC challenges during the COVID-19 pandemic empirically but with two crucial differences. First, an industry experiencing sharp demand downturns was analyzed with the automotive sector. Second, a unique sample of eight interconnected case companies, including manufacturers, suppliers, and machinery firms, was arranged. Based on current research, interviews with 35 SCM experts, and secondary material, the essay identifies characteristic pandemic challenges for a complex SC network along the disruption dimensions probability, duration, severity, propagation, and volatility. The results reveal the COVID-19 pandemic’s unique character compared to other SC disruptions. In this context, the paper’s network approach allows uncovering different perceptions of the same incident across individual firms, emphasizing the need for scholars to analyze SC disruptions from multiple angles. Moreover, the SC network’s countermeasures were analyzed, and novel SCRES measures along the levers agility, collaboration, SCRM culture, and SC (re-)engineering were uncovered. Overall, agility and collaboration measures showed the highest capacity to address characteristic pandemic challenges. However, a lack of preparedness impeded some measures’ full-scale application, encouraging practitioners to enhance proactive risk management following the pandemic. The fifth essay, “The Future of the Circular Economy and its Effect on Supply Chain Dependencies: Empirical Evidence from a Delphi Study,” adopts a forward-looking perspective, focusing on the time following the COVID-19 pandemic. It provides empirical evidence for the possibility of strengthening SCRES through the evolving CE trend. Based on RDT, the CE 4R taxonomy (reduce, reuse, recycle, recover), and expert discussions, 11 future projections for the year 2030 were developed. A group of 78 international CE and SCM experts quantitatively and qualitatively assessed the projections’ potential to reduce resource dependencies, their probability of occurrence, and their desirability. The results reveal that different CE practices offer varying capacities to reduce SC dependencies and thus improve SCRES. Particularly recycle and reduce techniques show considerable potential, hinting at essential synergies between the rapidly evolving CE and SCRES research fields. For instance, diversifying a company’s supply base by procuring recycled materials and components unveils the highest SCRES potential. Moreover, the paper presents that the CE practices’ implementation probability in 2030 is not congruent with the value retention hierarchy advocated by the 4R framework. Regulation, financial attractiveness, customer demand, technological innovation, and product design are the most prominent implementation barriers in this context. SCM practitioners can use the essay’s findings to drive their SCs’ ecological and resilient transformation simultaneously. The sixth and final research paper, “The Future of Industry 4.0 and Supply Chain Resilience after the COVID-19 Pandemic: Empirical Evidence from a Delphi Study,” does also take a foresight perspective. Building on the first essay on the relationship between I4.0 and SCRES, further SCRM literature, and expert discussions, 13 projections on SCRES opportunities and consequences resulting from different I4.0 technologies were elaborated. A panel including 64 international SCRM experts quantitatively and qualitatively evaluated the projections’ probability of occurrence until 2030, their SCRES potential, and their desirability through a two-round Delphi study. A fuzzy c-means algorithm was applied following the quantitative assessments to group the projections unbiasedly, leading to three explicit clusters. Overall, the findings reveal that I4.0 technologies will significantly improve SCRES over the next couple of years. Particularly projections on generating data, increasing visibility, and building digital capabilities received considerable approval and are perceived to improve SCRES in 2030. In contrast, statements requiring major supply network adaptations were deemed unlikely. For these projections, the essay explores specific barriers impeding implementation. Apart from closing the research gap on the future impact of I4.0 on SCRES, the paper also offers implications for practice. SC managers can use the results to gain a realistic impression of I4.0 SCRES potentials, prioritize investment decisions, and generate viable technology-enabled SCRM roadmaps for the coming years.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7007897263
Cites: 200
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10