Elusive Sleep: Healthcare Workers, Shift Work, and Implications for Worker Health and Patient Safety
Year: 2019
Type: article
Abstract: Problem: Sleep is as significant to wellness and disease prevention as diet and exercise.Yet, for healthcare workers rotating shifts and working hours outside 7am to 6pm, sleeping the recommended 7-9 hours in a 24-hour period can feel unattainable.Circadian rhythms, long work hours, and life's competing social obligations are just a few of the factors leading to healthcare worker short sleep (≤ 6 hours in a 24-hour period).Guided by the Social Ecological Model, the purpose of this manuscript option dissertation was to investigate how healthcare workers' sleep is impacted by the intersection of individual differences (biological and/or social) with shift work and organizational culture/policies.The three distinct projects included: (1) an integrative review investigating shift worker chronotype and association with obesity, (2) analysis of how registered nurse chronotype mismatched with shift timing may be associated with adverse health outcomes, and ( 3) explore sleep disrupting factors for hospital-based advanced practice providers (APPs) and the impact on patient care routines.Methods: Project 1 followed Polit and Beck's (2017) framework for literature reviews.Project 2 was a secondary analysis using logistic regression to estimate the odds ratio of obesity and CVD risk factors/disease among nurses with chronotype match or mismatch.Project 3 used an ethnographic research design, collecting, analyzing, and triangulating data from key informants (APPs) and key stakeholder interviews, on-site observations, and facility documents.Findings: Project (1) shift worker chronotype is associated with health issues, but limited number of studies on obesity prevented a strong determination.Evidence supported shift worker chronotype misaligned with shift timing demonstrates greater association for shortened sleep duration, decreased sleep quality, and increased risk for type 2 diabetes.Project (2) logistic regression analyses of chronotype match/mismatch with obesity and CVD risk factors/disease iii did not reveal relationships.Subgroup analyses demonstrated registered nurses with mismatched chronotype and above average sleep quality had an estimated 3.51 times the adjusted odds (95% CI 1.52,8.17;p=0.003) of being obese compared to matched chronotype and above average sleep quality nurses.Project (3) four themes emerged from the APP study including Social/Family Obligations and Value of Connectivity, Community Value of Sleep, Organizational Value of Sleep, and Individual Biology and How the Body Values Sleep.Key stakeholder data deviated from APPs' regarding how lack of sleep impacted APP mood (APPs can be "grumpy") and quality patient care (patient care items were occasionally overlooked, speed of work was slower).Additionally, sleep was not factored into root cause analysis studies.Conclusion: Healthcare worker short sleep causes are multidimensional, with individual, social, and organizational aspects intertwined.Interpersonal relations, patient care, and worker health can be impacted.Healthcare organizations should embrace sleep education programs to ensure workers are aware of risks for themselves and patients.Additional recommendations include policies with consistent messaging regarding the importance of sleep within safety culture and worker chronotype considerations in scheduling practices.Future research includes investigating effective education programs, examining integration of sleep into hospital safety policy and culture, and exploring effect of provider's short sleep on interpersonal relationships with patients and colleagues.iv
Author: Hittle, Beverly M
Institution: University of Cincinnati
Language: English
Subfield: Experimental and Cognitive Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
Funder: University of Cincinnati
OpenAlex ID: W7009563115
