Work

Homeland and Marxism: Ernst Bloch's dialectics of utopia

Year: 2017
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This thesis seeks to rediscover some key dialectical thoughts of the German philosopher Ernst Bloch for a critical rethinking of Marxism.The study is mainly motivated by three questions: (1) whether Bloch is blind towards historical failures and evils to the extent that his philosophy represents a sort of naïve optimism about the nature of human beings and the future of society; (2) whether Bloch's utopianism relies on the romanticism of the subject's imagination and disregards the objective tendencies in the world; and (3) how Bloch reassesses ideology and uses it to reinterpret Marxist thinking in return.Through investigating the dialectical tendencies in Bloch's ontology of Not-Yet, this thesis argues for Bloch's resistance to naïve optimism, subjectivism and the banal criticism of ideology by vulgar Marxism.Chapter 1, 'Darkness of the Lived Moment and Its Utopian Implications', examines the theory of the lived moment to present the dialectical contradictions inherent in Bloch's ontology.By informing readers of the interruptive feature of the subject's activity and experience of time, Bloch maintains the hardship of historical occurrence as well as the active role that subjectivity plays in historical advance, thus differentiating his theory from the naïve optimism of the advent of future.Chapter 2, 'The Dialectic of Subject-Object', focuses on Bloch's examination of the Not-Yet-Become in the world through phenomenology and his account of the immanent relation between nature and humans.I argue that the importance for utopian imagination to correlate with the objective world is unequivocal in Bloch's system, thus denying the criticism that his utopian theory is merely subjectivistic.Chapter 3, 'A Regulative Mechanism: Utopia and Dis-utopia', deals with Bloch's interpretation of ideology by proposing the presence of a regulative mechanism of utopia and dis-utopia in his theory.It is revealed that, for Bloch, utopia can exist in reactionary forms just as dis-utopia can emerge from within utopian thinking.The last chapter, 'Marxism and the Aufhebung of Religion', extends the discoveries of Chapter 3 to Bloch's engagement with religion.By identifying the idea of privatisation of religion as a Blochian intervention to Marx's criticism against the religious theories of the Young Hegelians, I propose to continue Bloch's viii thinking on the relationship of Marxism and religion for Marxian purposes.1 By the end of the thesis, some of the depth and dialectical richness of Ernst Bloch's theory will emerge, thereby contributing to future research on similar topics. 1 By 'Marxian purposes', I particularly denote to Bloch's vision on Marxism as a bridge to communicate and rediscover the utopian core within various forms of utopian thinking and even reactionary ideologies, as defined by traditional Marxism.Such a rediscovery is important for Marxism because it opens up a possibility of re-alliance with other forms of thinking so that the 'cold stream' of Marxism can be infused with the utopian passion for better society.In other words, it is a window for Marxism to better channel itself with some of the ancient thinking of the world that have been indispensable for social development as well.work in Bloch, functioning to resist the double stranglehold on utopian imagination from both capitalist ideologies and vulgar Marxism.It is revealed that utopia can exist in reactionary forms just as dis-utopia can emerge from within utopian thinking.The last chapter, 'Marxism and the Aufhebung of Religion', extends the discoveries of Chapter 3 to Bloch's engagement with religion.By inviting a Blochian intervention to Marx's criticism against the religious theories of the Young Hegelians (primarily those of Bauer and Feuerbach), I suggest that the idea of privatisation of religion can be a contact point between Marxism and religion. Why Bloch?Bloch was born into a Jewish family in 1885 in Ludwigshafen and died in 1977 in West Germany.His life was significantly shaped by many of the historical events in his time, such as the two World Wars, the rise of fascism and the building of the Berlin Wall.The words 'unaccepted' and 'exiled' best describe Bloch's life.His early life was defined by an unhappy childhood 3 and difficulty obtaining a teaching position at a university.Between his thirties and seventies, Bloch was exiled in Switzerland and America, eventually moving to West Germany, a capitalist country that he could not completely agree with.Even intellectually, Bloch was a double exile, as his theory was too heterodox for the East and too communistic for the West.Given Bloch's difficult life, it may be easy to think that he could not conceive of the theme of utopia and homeland; however, Bloch relentlessly preached hope.Thus, during my research on Bloch, the first thing that drew my attention to him was the contrast between his miserable life and his optimistic theory.From a boy's daydream to a bedtime fairy tale, from art and music to the subversive currents of religion, and from the most dis-utopian theme of death to even fascism, Bloch's investigations are coloured with an almost childlike optimism from beginning to end-he could always find the good among disparate phenomena.How could he be so hopeful after everything he experienced?Why did he place such an emphasis on hope?While I the other hand, 'dis-utopia' is intended for a more critical analysis.It goes beyond the negative definition of 'dystopia' with the acknowledgment that utopia still exists in dystopia.At this level, 'dis-utopia' is also a kind of critical dystopia, where tendencies of reversion is maintained in a dialectical way. 3 Vincent Geoghegan, Ernst Bloch (Florens: Routledge, 2008), 10. was surprised by the image of a child in Bloch's works, the image of an adult also became manifest with further research.For Bloch, the reminder of the open process of history was not to affirm a promising future; rather, it had a critical dimension of realising the evil and the danger.From the mysterious illumination of the darkness of the lived moment to the circulation of Nothing around the All, the negative is not absent in Bloch's theory.As a result, his tactics and strategies are more sophisticated than naïve.Indeed, as Bloch's life experiences reveal, there is simply no reality in which Bloch could remain naïve.This much more dialectical and apparent contradiction within Bloch's thinking also intrigues me.Indeed, if Bloch's theory was unacceptable in both the East and the West, it was not because of its eclecticism, but because it contained a double criticism of the unacceptableness of both parties.Bloch's thinking was a reminder of the fall of capitalism, which was not met with a desirable response from socialism.The turbulence of his time did not result in a satisfactory situation: while the old evil of capitalism continued to traverse the continents, with social imagination deeply impoverished, communism became increasingly equivalent to despotism and red terror, unable to centralise revolutionary forces.The era was restricted to forms of disbelief and frivolity, among which nihilism and hedonism are the two best examples.Thus, when the devils are released from the box and Marxism is not strong enough to subvert the situation, it is time to consider Bloch's message regarding the problems of socialism in our time so that Marxism can provide a genuine way out of the enchanted world.Bloch's innovative connection of Marxism and religion also intrigues me.Bloch opposes the conventional Marxist view that religion is merely 'false consciousness' and 'illusion', the idea that religion is merely an ideological tool that distorts people's perception of reality and serves the interests of the ruling class.He believes that Marx's own view of religion is far more complex because, as a fantastic realisation of human essence, religion speaks of humans' unfulfilled hopes regarding emancipation, which requires further definition by human work.In light of this, religion needs to be understood in its act of transcending and in the utopian character of humans that resorts to an identification of the present and a desired future.For Bloch, this atheistic core of religion has been preserved in Christian theology in its eschatological hope of God's kingdom.In 'space for challenging what is, for disrupting dominant assumptions about social and spatial 33 Hudson, Marxist Philosophy, 27, 30.
Source: Figshare
Author: Yazhi Li (20074959)
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7010354055
Cites: 101
Cited by:
Related to: 10