Year: 2024
Type: article
Abstract: During the last years, data-driven innovations have populated different aspects of individuals' daily lives.This has enabled the rise of platforms and the organisation of human activities around them.In return, this economic and sociological trend has caught the eye of regulators and policy makers worldwide who have answered with regulatory actions to open concentrated datasets for wider societal benefit.However, while data can enable further social development, it is also possible for data subjects to be exposed to more risks as a consequence.According to the GDPR, data processing activities can only be carried out if appropriate measures are adopted to mitigate or nullify any potential harm that individuals might suffer, as demonstrated by several obligations imposed by the GDPR to both controllers and processors.While there are different sorts of safeguards ¾from technical and organisational measures up to data protection impact assessments¾, transparency can serve as such when it comes to data processing activities, in particular those organised around consent as a legal basis.Current policy strategies and new data-related regulations emphasise consent as the 'preferred' legal basis to put data subjects in the loop about what is going on with their personal data and 'legitimatise' activities that have been under the regulatory spotlight.However, according to research conducted on the matter, transparency is highly ineffective in its current form, mainly as privacy notices.While many regulatory fields have taken a disclosure-based approach to balance asymmetries, transparency requirements play a significant role in the financial services industry, where some of these shortcomings have been addressed through active advice obligations.While in the realm of financial law an 'assist the client' duty has emerged to help individuals make choices about their finances, the same cannot be said for the data protection law field.Given that data controllers are required to follow a risk-based approach and should deploy appropriate safeguards to mitigate or prevent any harm to the data subjects and thus ensure transparency's effectiveness, we can argue that a similar duty to help individuals in making choices about their data could exist.This is particularly relevant as consent would seem the preferred legal basis for sharing and re-using data in digital platforms.This dissertation shall discuss the emergence of this duty of assistance and ask whether a wrong implementation can constitute a dark pattern that would invalidate any attempt to help data subjects in making free and informed choices in a complex environment.The dissertation will also explore how this duty in data protection can be made trustworthy by analysing trust-enhancing elements present in data-related regulations.Particularly, the analysis will focus on how to effectively implement this in a varied and diverse platform ecosystem where distinct stakeholders operate, each with a particular data culture and regulatory background, such as open finance.Ultimately, this duty of assistance would also help other fields where data-intensive activities are gaining tracking and data subjects are exposed to numerous choices on a daily basis.
Author: Andrès Chomczyk Penedo
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: data consent, transparency, duty to assist, dark patterns, GDPR, personal data protection, informed consent, privacy policies, open finance, digital platforms, data protection impact assessment, data subject rights, risk-based approach, data sharing and reuse, financial regulation, regulatory asymmetry, data culture, platform ecosystems
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7011260269
