Work

Mellan rätt och verklighet - Om grundläggande behov och mänskliga rättigheter i häkte för personer med fysisk funktionsnedsättning

Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The right to fundamental needs and human rights applies to everyone, regard- less of whether they are deprived of their liberty, have a disability, or are affected by a combination of these circumstances. Although deprivation of liberty may justify certain restrictions, such as limitations on the right to freedom, it should not result in more extensive restrictions on rights than are necessary to achieve the aims of criminal justice. Despite being one of the most intrusive coercive measures, pre-trial detention can be considered necessary for conducting an effective criminal investigation. Persons with disabilities are a particularly vulnerable group in society in general, and even more so when deprived of their liberty. For individuals with disabilities to receive an equivalent implementation of pre-trial detention as other individuals, the right conditions must be ensured both in theory and in practice. This thesis aims to examine both national and international legal frameworks that are intended to guarantee that persons with physical disabilities have their fundamental needs met within the Swedish remand system. Furthermore, it analyzes how the CRPD is reflected in the Swedish detention system and how this aligns with the right to have one's basic needs met. Finally, the thesis includes a survey conducted with defense attorneys and prison staff, to highlight practical challenges in the encounter with detainees who have physical disabilities. The Swedish remand system is relatively well-regulated and largely fulfills Sweden’s obligations under the CRPD. Although the thesis shows that there is a lack of specific regulation regarding the treatment of persons with physical disabilities, the primary issues are identified as the practical application of existing rules, the inaccessibility of detention facilities, and insufficient staff knowledge. Particularly prominent are the shortcomings in accessibility and adaptation of detention environments. In this context, the limited applicability of the Discrimination Act is highlighted as especially problematic. Although the Swedish Prison and Probation Service is not covered by the Act’s prohibition against inadequate accessibility, the agency still has an obligation to ensure accessibility in accordance with both the CRPD and national disability policy. The most significant consequence of the Prison and Probation Service not being fully subject to the protections of the Discrimination Act is that individuals' ability to effectively assert their rights is limited. This, in turn, risks rendering those rights as well-intentioned principles that lack real impact in practice.
Institution: Lund University
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7011531107
Cites: 12
Cited by:
Related to: 10