Work

Medical Students’ Perceptions of their Self-Regulation in the Pre-Clinical Medical School Curriculum: A Phenomenological Exploration

Year: 2017
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Medical schools are environments where students are expected to learn a voluminous amount of information very quickly. Admission committees consider various criteria as they seek to admit the most qualified and well-prepared applicants to their institution. However, the stringent criteria used are not a guarantee that all students will complete the curriculum without significant academic challenges, failed blocks of coursework or dismissal. Some students may not have optimal academic or self-regulation skills required to learn the material sufficiently and perform well on exams. \nSelf-regulated learners are conscientious learners who pay attention to the subject matter, their learning process, weakness areas and ways to improve. As the literature suggests, successful students use self-regulation skills to achieve and sustain academic success, thus it is necessary for students struggling in the curriculum to develop the skills of self-monitoring or assessment, judgment, and self-reaction to avoid or minimize negative events as they work toward their educational goals. \nThe research on self-regulation in medical school curriculum has focused on self-regulatory behavior in specific courses or only in one portion of the curriculum. This study proposed to augment the existing literature by inquiring about perceptions of self-regulatory behavior from medical students who have experienced academic challenges in the first two years of medical school curriculum. \nThe qualitative phenomenological study was conducted at a medium-sized school of medicine located in the southwestern region of Texas. Participants were current medical students who had a shared phenomenon of academic challenges in the pre-clinical years of the medical curriculum. Data collection occurred through the lens of the researcher, semi-structured interviews, and field notes. The data was then analyzed through the constant-comparative method, as well as thematic analysis. \nThe results of this research study found that research participants varied in awareness of their self-regulation when encountering academic difficulties. Most participants had some level of awareness of self-regulation, but few were acutely aware. Additionally, the ability of medical students to accurately assess their self-regulatory behavior can be weak or deficient. Participants indicated there were difficulties they encountered while in the curriculum that interfered with their self-regulatory skills. These interferences were internal for some students and external for others, but nonetheless interfered with the participants’ ability to consistently self-regulate successfully. Participants also revealed they are aware of the services available for student support with most indicating they used at least one, and some indicating they received assistance from three or four services. \n The implications of this study for higher education and medical education practice are the variability in awareness of self-regulation by high performing students when encountering academic difficulties. Because awareness of self-regulation varies among students, education institutions must take proactive steps to increase awareness of the self-regulatory skills necessary to perform successfully in medical school. \nParticipants shared issues, attitudes, or conditions that interfered with successful self-assessing and self-regulating in the medical curriculum. Additional implications for higher education are that high-performing students encounter difficulties in the curriculum that interfere with their self-regulatory skills, and that medical students are reluctant to seek resources or services when first encountering academic difficulties. \n The results of this study lead to the following recommendations for higher education and medical education. By providing education and information to students at matriculation or soon thereafter about the self-regulation process and skills necessary for successful completion of medical school, medical education may limit the academic difficulties encountered by students in the pre-clinical curriculum. Also, by providing opportunities for students to discuss the importance of accurate self-assessment with panels of upper level student and medical professionals, meaningful conversations with those who have practiced this skill successfully can occur. Finally, by educating medical students about the personal and academic challenges that can occur in medical school, and providing the resources for students to manage these challenges, the number of students who complete the medical curriculum successfully with minimal or no academic difficulties may be increased. \nThe findings of this study will contribute to higher education and medical education practice by expansion of the knowledge base of educators to successfully guide and support students experiencing academic difficulty. This is one of the few studies that examine the perceptions of medical students regarding their self-regulatory behaviors in the pre-clinical curriculum. Additional studies should be conducted to further expand this research into additional medical institutions and to focus on medical students at all levels of academic performance.
Author: Perrin, Allison
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7011560393
Cites: 85
Cited by:
Related to: 9