Multidisciplinary Approaches towards the Effective Management of Illegal, Unreported and Unregulated Fishing in Large Scale Marine Protected Areas
Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Marine biodiversity has been in decline for decades and has not abated despite concerted efforts to create areas of refuge through the implementation of marine protected areas (MPA). Many have attributed this to the ongoing presence of human activities in these areas. Amongst the most damaging is illegal, unreported and unregulated (IUU) fishing which continues to cause species declines and habitat degradation. Effectively combatting IUU fishing in large-scale MPAs (LSMPAs) is particularly challenging given their large geographic scales and remote locations and will require multidisciplinary approaches that transcend traditional fisheries management techniques. In this thesis, I explore global drivers of IUU fishing and investigate ways of improving the efficiency and effectiveness of enforcement operations within LSMPAs, drawing on a range of data science and social research methods. In Chapter 1, I combine a systematic literature review with a survey of MPA professionals to create a comprehensive assessment of the drivers of IUU fishing. I discover that a lack of enforcement is consistently ranked as the most important driver, however, publication bias in the scientific literature may have underestimated the prospect of higher catch in driving IUU fishing, although this could also be symptomatic of speculation amongst experts. Furthermore, the relative importance of drivers of IUU fishing vary substantially according to MPA attributes suggesting that bespoke management interventions are needed to ensure that enforcement operations are effective. In Chapter 2, I review historical data for the pelagic longline fishery that operated within the Ascension Island EEZ prior to the implementation of a ‘no-take’ MPA. I reveal a clear hotspot of activity that corresponds closely with the contemporary high seas fleet at Ascension Island which may provide a focal point for enforcement. In Chapter 3, I combine data and social science approaches to investigate the effectiveness of patrol-based enforcement activities on IUU fishing within the Chagos Archipelago MPA and show that actions taken by the Sri Lankan government to improve the monitoring of their fleet may provide greater deterrence than current enforcement strategies. Finally, in Chapter 4, I develop and validate a machine learning approach to forecast IUU fishing risk in LSMPAs based on the environmental niches of fleets. I demonstrate high levels of prediction accuracy when sufficient training data is available for vessels fishing in adjacent regions that are also representative of the fleet that poses an IUU fishing risk.
Author: C Kerry
Institution: University of Exeter
Language: English
Subfield: Aquatic Science
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: green
Award: G7677611432
OpenAlex ID: W7011564648
