Work

Assemble with care

Year: 2024
Type: article
Abstract: Our everyday lives are increasingly entangled with ubiquitous but invisible data and algorithmic systems.These systems are becoming a matter of fact of our everyday.Almost no aspect of our lives exist that has not been curated, mediated, ordered, and structured based on algorithmic systems: the news and media we consume, our potential dates, the music we listen do, the ads we see, the prices for goods and services we are offered.While this might seem innocent, the evidence is mounting daily about the potential risks and harms this algorithmic ordering of the social brings with itself.This thesis takes these algorithmic matters of fact as matters of concern.Using the notion of algorithmic governmentality to describe the state of as if agency that individuals have within the human-algorithms assemblages, this thesis aims to find the counterpoints and the counterconducts against this governmentality to enable meaningful human agency as a precondition for digital sovereignty.To do this a number of empirical studies have been conducted.The aim of these studies is to both inquire about the requirements for agency of the individuals themselves entangled in these systems, and to investigate how they can be technically translated into technology design.As a result of these inquiries, I propose the notion of agency affordances understood as tools and mechanisms for assembling meaningful human agency by programming it via the technical infrastructures and for facilitating it via the societal structures.Borrowing from the theories of the semiotician A.J. Greimas and transposing them into the realm of the algorithmic, this thesis further develops an analytical, conceptual, and practical framework for investigating and enabling meaningful human agency.Another crucial contribution of this thesis is that is also serves as a study in research methods regarding investigating data and algorithmic systems.Adopting the approach of thinking and researching with care and trying to navigate the technical affordances of algorithmic systems that constrain our field of research, a number of approaches are developed that propose productive mechanisms of opening for research.By incorporating the approaches of critical companionship, critical pedagogy and studying up, this thesis also maps productive and empowering and avenues for participatory research.This first Part introduces the topic of this thesis and the personal and academic motivations for pursuing it.It sets the scene by presenting the issues that are its main matter of concern -the data and algorithmic systems we are entangled in are the object of its investigation.I briefly introduce some of the main conceptualizations to define the nature of this entanglement -I use the concepts of algorithmic governmentality and digital sovereignty to discuss how things are at the moment (governmentality) and how things should be (sovereignty).I briefly point to the substantial gap I identified when it comes to conceptualizing and investigating the issue of meaningful human agency, and to the theory I reach out to resolve it.This introductory part also elaborates on the research objectives, the particular questions, and the specific approaches developed to investigate them.This part ends with practical information, such as the structure of the thesis and how to read it.Part I. Introduction Chapeau 5 Part I. Introduction Chapeau 14 the regulatory proposals, although I do use some of their tools in my research.I briefly elaborate on this in the Chapter 6.3. Research approach(es)how we come to know things shapes how we come to act (McQuillan, 2022, p.103)As I have already hinted in the earlier sections, two notions are crucial and present predominantly in this thesis.The first one is the notion of "assemblage" -both as a noun and as a verb.As a noun, it describes how I approach data and algorithmic systems.Following a long tradition in Science and Technology Studies (STS), in Media and Communication Studies (MCS), and critical data and algorithm studies, understanding technology as assemblage means conceptualizing and studying algorithmic systems and their workings as particular temporary gatherings of human and non-human actors and elements who are in perpetual and constant process of arrangements, and which are embodied in their relationality that produces particular technological and societal effects.Looking at algorithms as socio-technical assemblages means that their studying will require not focusing on only one of the elements or actors (either technical or societal), but looking at them across the system, in their relationality (Ananny & Crawford, 2018).As a verb, it means that in my investigation, aiming towards comprehensiveness, my goal is to assemble actors and things -I look at the various nodes in the human-algorithmic assemblage (people, practices, and arrangements), but also in their edges.To borrow from Iliadis & Russo (2016), I will scavenge (Seaver, 2017) insights from the systems of thoughts and practicesof the communities of practice developing data and algorithmic systems, I will look in the inscribed and performed forms of knowledge and epistemic understandings, I will investigate the governmentalities, and sometimes look and borrow from the legalities, I will take into considerations the political economy, ideologies and goals of institutions and organizations, at the normativities, imaginaries, the needs and requirements of the human parts of the humanalgorithmic assemblage.But I would also look into the materialities and infrastructures, in the technicity of the algorithmic artifacts themselves, the "black-boxes" and the constituting parts of algorithmic systems (e.g., data and data sources).I will also look into how the algorithmic, the technical is situated in the world and how is the world, the societal situated in it (Dumit, 2014).Uncovering their mutual embeddedness, their formed relations, and coming together will enable me (us) to learn more about the power relations, politics, interests, normativities -the things existing outside the artifact that affect its use and the people around it.Part I. Introduction Chapeau 15 I do this by approaching my investigation by thinkingand researching with care.This is the second important thread in my thesis.Adopting with-care lenses and approaches means that critical attention is given to the situated, to the tangible, to the enactments, to the arrangements and the unfolding of the algorithmic socio-technical assemblages.Building on Latour's (2004) matters of fact and concern, and on Haraway's (1988) situated knowledge, de la Bellacasa (2011, 2012) calls for treating the matters of facts and the socio-technical assemblages as matters of care, because care has a great significance for the construction of knowledge (2011, p. 85) My research can be qualified as one of care through the practices and study-arrangements I undertook in regard to my participants.For each study activity that required soliciting insights, experiences, personal data, and engagement from my study participants, I undertook a number of care-ful arrangements for data collection, protection, and processing.I approach my participants as individuals with their own specificities, who are all differently and experientially entangled with(in) data and algorithmic systems, and who have different needs, requirements and understanding of these systems.I approached each and every one of them as "worthy to be heard" -including the experts from the community of practice that I interviewed (Chapter 5.2).But more importantly, for enabling an environment and processes where my participants could think with care, and where algorithmic concerns will become matters of care.By adopting the with-care lenses and approach, I am aiming with my research to also empower my research participants.As Dombroski (2018) says, "we must operate our academic analyses of care in such a way as to support, construct, and enact collective change" (p.3).What constitutes thinking and researching with care is to enable my participants a "situated, practice-informed, and affective knowledge about technologies" (Zakharova & Jarke, 2024, p. 656) and our own entanglement with them.As de la Bellacasa (2011) outlines, "transforming things into matters of care is a way of relating to them, of inevitably becoming affected by them, and of modifying their potential to affect others" (p.99).That can be achieved by employing thinking-with-care (de la Bellacasa, 2012; Lupton, 2020; see also Zakharova & Jarke, 2024), understood as generating awareness and paying attention to the affective, to the responsiveness, "and attentiveness to the affective as well as social, cultural, and political dimensions of these assemblages" (Lupton, 2020, p. 3169).According to de la Bellacasa (2011), different actors within the human-algorithms assemblage might be implicated or entangled in certain matters of concern, but not being able to recognize this entanglement, or to voice or make knowable their concerns.To overcome this, she proposes to do thinking with care "as an active process of intervening in the count of whom and what is ratified as concerned" (p.52).Part I. Introduction Chapeau 16 This means that as scholars, we should treat our research as ongoing, as an open and a collective inquiry, which should bring insights and transformations through collaboration, adaptation, but also learning (see also Lupton, 2020; Dombroski, 2018; Van der Velden and Sjåfjell, 2023).The call for thinking and researching with care also means empowering others (my research subjects) to care and to consequently -do (something about it).As Joks and Law (2017) outline, this opens the questions of who has the power to care, outlining that caring is intrinsically also related to agency -if you care, you should be doing something.Although often, not much can be done.Thinking with care, when doing science, according to de la Bellacasa, should fa
Author: Ana Pop Stefanija
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7014073654
FWCI:
Cites: 290
Cited by:
Related to: 10